Although encrypted, the data is unencrypted when you decrypt it!
They should at least add double ROT-13...
Did whoever wrote this realize you need to be able to recover the cleartext for this to even work?
Although encrypted, the data is unencrypted when you decrypt it!
They should at least add double ROT-13...
Did whoever wrote this realize you need to be able to recover the cleartext for this to even work?
Now, I know the answer is so that you can have push notifications sent to your mobile phone with every IMAP poll Microsoft does on your behalf, but that’s because the architecture of the new Outlook app likely borrows features of the Accompli mobile app they bought and maintained as Outlook mobile. That the desktop app re-uses the same APIs as the mobile app rather than process mail locally makes sense from a code reuse and efficiency standpoint, but really only because your accounts can seamlessly carry over to all your devices.
It’s arguable that the distinction between keeping your password in the cloud and keeping your password local is a security risk. However, if you previously used Outlook.com to check your IMAP email, and maybe this is where the feature derives from, then you already provided your IMAP password to Microsoft on the web. Likewise Google for importing IMAP to Gmail. We do this because it is nicer to get one inbox and one push notification across multiple accounts - when we want cloud providers checking emails for us.
It is less clear why a desktop app would do this unless you opted in to fancier service of some kind - e.g. viewing emails on the web when not at this device, or push notifications to your mobile phone, etc.
If Microsoft wanted to read your emails even with a locally stored and never shared IMAP password, they could still send telemetry derived from the local client to build an advertising profile based on local emails, or to display targeted ads. They don’t technically need your password to read your emails if you are using their email client.
Both Gmail and Outlook are receiving passwords, then using those to perform IMAP requests from their servers. The difference is that Gmail had permission to do so, while Outlook did not.
It would be fine if Outlook was backing up encrypted data and then not sending the decryption key to Microsoft servers.
It could have been phrased better, but the clear message is that Microsoft has pilfered access to unencrypted passwords, regardless of any transportation-level encryption.
This is not a translation error either. The same mistake can be found in the German original.
> Did whoever write this realize you need to be able to recover the cleartext for this to even work?
The first author of the article has a degree in 'commercial information technology' and has worked as a sysadmin, so I assume they do understand that this is necessary, they may just have done a bad job of expressing that.
An article in a technical outlet should still do better in such regards.