If you're racking up wives, all the more reason to save money. Alternatively, I could imagine a new wife becoming quite upset upon learning that her engagement ring was from a pawn shop...possibly upset enough to leave!
I might sound like an asshole, but if she's upset enough to leave you over that you should let her go. I wouldn't want a wife like that, personally.
They shared the ring too! Maximum efficiency.
"One Ring to rule them all"
Phone autocorrected the missing apostrophe to a multiple instead