The only way SpaceX is going to move forward is becoming more ambitious with a new project.
The risk isn't that if the Starship doesn't work, but that the R&D time takes too long or too much money to complete.
The only way SpaceX is going to move forward is becoming more ambitious with a new project.
The risk isn't that if the Starship doesn't work, but that the R&D time takes too long or too much money to complete.
Well to be fair, there’s a lot of technology at spacex no one else has. One example, the Raptor engine’s combination of size, efficiency, and thrust is just not available to anyone other than SpaceX. Even if exact schematics were stolen you’d still need to obtain the recipes for the alloys used and how to manufacture them. Companies gave up on full flow staged combustion as just not feasible but SpaceX figured it out and is on v3 of perfecting it.
What's happening is that other companies are slow to wake up and adapt.
I think most other organizations have a lot more bureaucracy involved in making changes, which makes them slower and more expensive.
Plus, SpaceX doesn't try to spread out its operations across the US to act like a jobs program, while the other big space contractors have advertised their presence in every state as a reason they should be picked, which obviously increases costs.
So when someone comes along that optimizes on cost and velocity and eschews cost plus contracts, that can be very difficult to deal with.
Also, as other people have mentioned, they pretty clearly do have exceptional tech - they routinely land orbital class boosters which has only been done with prototype rockets (it's very different landing when you can hover vs when you can't). And Raptor and Merlin are among the best rocket engines that have ever been made.
And even more impressive than specific components is their production and operational expertise. Being able to launch so many rockets flawlessly is a truly astounding feat. In a couple of years, Falcon 9 might even beat out the RD-108/107's total accumulated flight time record, which I thought wouldn't happen for a very long time.
Edit: for context, the RD-108/107 are the engines used on the Soyuz, which (as a family) has a truly astounding number of flights. To be fair to SpaceX, though, Soyuz accumulated those over many decades.
Hell, he got in trouble for false statements about Tesla, which is publicly held.
Elon's stated position on an IPO is that they'll wait until they can predict cashflow reasonably well.
Edit: Also, to be precise, she said they had made a profit in Q4 2022. So, it could just be referring to the costs vs income of that quarter specifically rather than a general statement that Starlink is in the green now. After all, since then they've upped their flight rate significantly.
They also need to launch more satellites to increase capacity and add most customers. The big question is how many potential customers are out there, and if they will be enough to maintain the network.
I'd bet that SpaceX has some huge loans and/or bonds issues outstanding, based on future StarLink revenues. There isn't that much revenue from their other sources, and "build out the network, collect the monthly fees" is the sort of business model that banks and bond investors love.
They also had Tesla to bail out SolarCity after SpaceX basically used NASA to buy their bonds and prop them up, which wasn't enough and they were about to fail.
It is a different category of risk, though, with a different perception bias.
For an analogy: becoming obese is probably more risky than BASE jumping, as the diseases that come with being too fat are horrible. But people don't perceive those two risks in the same way.