While shamefully chucking RS-25s into the ocean
Sure, RS-25s were designed to be reusable. But it's not like they were being used for anything; they were just hanging out in a warehouse since the Shuttle days. If NASA was going to put them in a museum or something it would have already happened.
At least this way, they get used for what they were designed for.
SLS is going to be tossing four RS-25 engines per launch (with *each* engine costing the same as ~2-3 entire Falcon 9 launches) into the ocean as the planned course of action. That is by design - and not some accident during a test flight.