This refrain is beginning to sound like the "checkmate atheists" of people who don't understand biology
I think it's perfectly far to be very very critical of these paper especially because of the impact they can have on society, medicine, and legislation.
We should be very harsh and disciplined.
I fully agree with your comment out of context, and I think it actually backs up GP's point about not lazily dismissing stuff as "in rats"
These animal studies are way too preliminary to waste time discussing by non-biologists. I think that the press popularizing these very preliminary studies as science actually serves to undermine the perception of science in the general population.