How would you figure out which memory location stored a given thing, e.g. # of lives?
But for stuff where exact matching wasn't practical like say a more or less continous health-bar, you could instead filter by searching for values that decreased / increased / didn't change.
Of course you would also have to guess at the data type but there weren't that many likely choices.
Either that, or you'd just go about trying one by one until you found it, then tried to figure out a pattern of what was around it and make notes on a paper for next time.