Five women got eye syphilis from the same man–raising questions
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
It is transferred directly. From bacteria on the skin, pressed against the skin or, more often, a mucous membrane. In the initial stage there's usually a skin ulceration which is infectious. In later stages, it's rather generalized (e.g. anywhere a rash or blistering occurs may be able to pass the infection on).
It's probably best thought of as a close-contact or mucous-membrane-contact disease. Nonsexual contact is known to pass it.
There are closely related diseases [1] [2] [3] that can be passed non-sexually.
The eye is one of the places where a primary ulcer shows up - but it's rarely the first site. To have it show up there repeatedly suggests the possibility of an unusual sexual practice yes. Probably more like rubbing the body then the face with the hands than what you were thinking. But that should have come up when they questioned the five women.
The hypothesis presented seems plausible: a subtype evolved to be particularly fond of the eyes.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonvenereal_endemic_syphilis
To have it show up in the eye repeatedly may simply indicate it’s travelled back down the nerve.
The pathway is not even rare, so I wonder what is newsworthy here. e.g. 500k Americans live with herpes simplex keratitis (or “eye herpes”) though many don’t realise, and you don’t see that on HN frontpage.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/syphilis/symp...
The article ends sighting the rise in STIs and yet this walking Petri dish wasn't tested for syphilis? The test can't be *that* expensive, especially in the context of public health.
Why wouldn't such ppl get a broader range of tests? Are the doctors prevented from ordering such tests? Either at the same time, or as a follow up? The guy had physical malformations that tested negative for herpes and there was no, "Well, what is it then?"
Don’t do this. Stigmatizing infectious disease leads to people not getting tested, which leads to more disease and more suffering.
This patient was treated for the concern that he presented and, for reasons we don’t know, didn’t follow up. Some people don’t have a lot of time and money to pursue the details of something that appears resolved, and it’s not clear that the tests would even been covered.
Standing around at a hospital and then fighting with your insurance company isn’t anybody’s idea of a fun.
Or does it encourage people to hide from the problem, exacerbating it? I know weight shaming is in this category, tends to make people gain rather than lose.
Do you know if this actually works? Is this definitely positive behaviour, or does it just feel like it?
If you want to sleep with different people on a regular or semi-regular basis, you should be getting STI checks, and you should be practicing safe sex. That is a basic element of being a decent person.
What you're saying is that I am shaming someone for bad driving when I tell them they should stop at red lights. After they've repeatedly run red lights.
If you are having sex with other people, you have a duty to them to ensure that you aren't transmitting a variety of different diseases and illnesses, at least not without consent. Many STIs are easily and quickly, detected and treated, but many others are permanent and carry life long risks, and if you are too lazy or "embarrassed" to get tested, then you have no business sleeping with other people.
My only question was if shaming people is effective, and we seem to have sidestepped that.
I did not mention their hygiene, sexual or otherwise.
If you
1. Have multiple sexual partners
2. Don't get regular STI tests
you are in the wrong. I am not shaming hygiene, shaming STIs, shaming the number (high or low, I literally do not care what consensual adults are doing with or without clothes), shaming the frequency (again, don't care).
I am saying that the basic social contract of sleeping with someone is that you are open and honest about your sexual health, and in the absence of explicitly saying you have an STI the reasonable assumption your partners are making is that you have a reasonable belief you are not carrying anything transmissible. To be able to do that you need to have regular STI checks.
You're right that shaming someone for having an STI is not helpful, especially given a number of STIs aren't curable, but not getting tested is a _choice_, and shaming people at risk of STIs for not getting tested is no different from shaming people for drunk driving. You are making a bad choice and expecting no consequences.
Why do you think people choose not to get tested?
The tests are free in almost any other context. Planned Parenthood and tons of other NGOs offer them no questions asked and Obamacare made their coverage by insurance mandatory. Many (most?) states even subsidize the tests for the obvious public health benefits.
Emergency rooms are just a special case where the economic incentives are even more completely out of wack than in the rest of healthcare. It could have been something as trivial as understaffing - the full STD panel might have required two vials of blood and a genital swab so they went with the simpler test as labor triage.
It seems a bit of a stretch to call this "first of its kind." Regardless of the mechanistic details, the transmission was still sexual, which is how Syphillis has always spread. It would be "first of its kind" if this cluster were linked to transmission through other means...
After reading the article, I'm not even clear what's notable about this incident, other than maybe that this specific strain happens to primarily target the ocular system (which isn't unusual anyway). Multiple people had sex with the same syphillis-infected partner, and now they all have syphillis. News at 11...
BTW: has anyone considered the chilling effect that contact tracing exemptions to HIPPA have on STI testing? Maybe this guy was hard to track down because he didn't want to be found. Maybe he didn't complete the testing procedures because he didn't want his name logged in the database as someone with syphillis...