- Ocarina of Time
- Final Fantasy VII
- Baldur's Gate
- Starcraft
- Metal Gear Solid
- Resident Evil 2
- Pokemon Yellow
If only it was as competitive as 2023, in which some of the top games were:
- A Zelda game
- A Final Fantasy game
- A Resident Evil remake
- A Baldur's Gate game
If you had a taste for a certain kind of game in the late 90s you didn't have many choices that were done by a full studio and polished. Most of the games you listed had the same "problem" of being unparalleled at the time.
Now you have a lot of clones of the same idea, plus so many of the classics are still replayable or remastered and rereleased. A good-but-not-great game has many substitutes with a similar scope and feel.