Court Rebukes DOJ, Says Hacking Required to Be Prosecuted as Hacker
wired.com
wired.com
What the DoJ wants is an easy, flexible statutory framework that will let them shortcut prosecutions in cases like this, where you have a clear bad-actor for whom non-CFAA cases would be complicated and expensive to pursue. Remember, the guy who evaded CFAA prosecution in this article isn't a hero. (Read the whole article for the [strictly white collar] criminality he's accused of, but fair warning: it's boring white collar stuff).
That doesn't make the DoJ right. It probably shouldn't be super easy for them to make complex cases simply by citation to computer terms of service. But it also doesn't automatically signal the intention of every single government entity to take over the "free Internet".
An extremely excellent study of the issues at play in defining "abuse" and "unauthorized access":
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=399740
Strongly recommend reading the whole thing. It covers a giant swath of almost any computer-based legal drama likely to hit HN.
Tomato, tomahto. The problem is in who decides who is a bad actor.
You suggest that CFAA cases, along with SOPA and PIPA, are evidence of a DoJ that wants to sieze control of the open Internet.
I'm saying that what the DoJ wants with the CFAA is a clear "technicality" statute they can use to simplify charging fraud cases (like this one, which appears to be just straight up fraud).
This isn't a "tomato tomahto" distinction.
> Judges and juries decide that
Once something actually goes to trial.What if the DoJ's 'bad guy' is really innocent? If they have too much power, then how much stress and drama does the DoJ get to drag someone through just because an agent of the DoJ doesn't like him/her that much (maybe just rubbed them the wrong way, so they 'must' be the 'bay guy').
Based on the criteria set in the legislation that creates the penalties.
This fails to reassure me.
Laws are abstract concepts easily broken: especially by those who write them. Laws have never assured security (and that goes for things beyond just the internet).