It is on topic - Google has the exact same openness issues that these other companies have, and yet Brin fails to mention this.
Even more so, considering the vast amount of information they DO have.
If they think it's a problem they should stop doing it themselves.
Your standard for credibility ensures the speakers suicide, at which point there is no conversation to be had because the remaining players don't give a damn.
How do you suggest they go about handling this?
Edited for brevity.
Painting themselves as somehow superior while they engage in the same behavior doesn't seem likely to engender trust.