"They can't buy machines from this Swiss company!" is not really much of a barrier when we look at the resources they have available. Over 12 months, that is a problem for them. Maybe 5 years. In a decade, ASML relying very heavily on the CCP shooting themselves and their people in the foot to still be a differentiator.
When talking about the sheer scale of 10% of the globe's population, you need a lot more than one technical dot point to say they can't do something.
Don’t disagree with your general point though. Also there is always the option of industrial espionage as we have seen.
Leaving the politics aside, it will be interesting to see what technical solutions emerge if the ‘easy’ option of spending a few hundred million dollars on a couple of EUV machines isn’t available.
And I'd assume the answer is spending a few billion dollars developing a couple of EUV machines over a long time. It isn't like a billion dollars is much money and the Chinese economy is reaching the point where people will be looking to muscle in to precision manufacturing. It isn't like cheap labour is an option any more. They've already overwhelmed the Europeans in a bunch of phone and computer related areas so there is evidence that the Europeans probably can't maintain a competitive edge if the Chinese want to get good at something.
Honestly, given what happened with the iPhone and Nokia I don't know how anyone is placing faith in the Chinese not being able to catch up. European tech companies have a history of looking unbeatable until they're just knocked completely out of the race. If anything the threat is that Europe won't be able to keep up with Asia.
China is not the first to take a crack at this. Attempts to replicate and catch up with American and European chipmaking and computing efforts go back to the dawn of the discipline, and had involved some of the largest economies of their times, yet here we are.
We now know it works. Before, why should China bother when they can just buy from western suppliers and TSMC instead? Now we gave China no other choice but to invest 10-20 years into this until they have something that works. This is why you see all the chip manufacturing equipment makers in China have something like 150-200% YoY growth in the past 3 years. Their R&D centers are pursuing multiple avenues to make sub-5nm chips possible. Not only multiple avenues of making EUV work, but also non-EUV avenues. It just so happens that starting this year we know that nanoimprint lithography works, and is cheaper than EUV. Huawei's newest CPU performs on par with CPUs on smaller nodes. That's because Huawei invested heavily in CPU design and heat dissipation technology. They haven't even gone into advanced packaging yet.
Will they stay behind western technology forever because we have an R&D lead? People who claim this are ignoring a big factor: they will no longer be able to profit from Chinese buyers. These profits are necessary for future R&D investment, which is necessary to maintain the lead and R&D speed.
That's debatable.
Samsung, a behemoth in Korea and one of the largest holdings in the world, has tried to compete with TSMC at the same node size, and failed so far.
> Will they stay behind western technology forever because we have an R&D lead? People who claim this are ignoring a big factor: they will no longer be able to profit from Chinese buyers.
Doesn't this work the other way around as well? Chinese companies in the same space will not be able to profit from EU and North American customers, historically the largest spenders.
> Doesn't this work the other way around as well?
It does. But the difference is:
- They're coming from behind and enjoy latecomer's advantage. They can take advantage of western R&D results. They may not be able to obtain all the details, but just knowing that a particular R&D path is viable is already an advantage.
- They have a captive market thanks to sanctions.
- They're coming from a smaller size. Chinese semiconductor companies had such small market share that capturing even a small part of only the Chinese market already translates to tremendous growth. They can only go up while the western supply chain will go down.
Finally, there's the global south which is also growing. This is a huge market that they can sell to. In the future, western suppliers will have to compete with Chinese suppliers in this market, even if Chinese suppliers are locked out of western markets.
That wording is a bit harsh. They haven't failed, but they haven't been able to compete at scale, which is what matters.
> They're coming from behind and enjoy latecomer's advantage. They can take advantage of western R&D results.
Isn't that the main issue, that they can't?
> They have a captive market thanks to sanctions.
That isn't true. Current sanctions target exports of certain consumer and professional products, none of which are chips as far as I understand; and imports of certain products branded strategic such as AI related hardware.
> They're coming from a smaller size. Chinese semiconductor companies had such small market share that capturing even a small part of only the Chinese market already translates to tremendous growth.
I don't think this means anything in this context. Capturing a larger chunk of a single market doesn't even mean that they are better than most at what they do, just that their go to market strategy is more effective than their competitors. SMIC could be releasing chips with comically large transistors, as long as their scale and prices are preferable to those of their competitors.
> They can only go up while the western supply chain will go down.
This is wishful thinking, at best. But again, growth means nothing here. SMIC could "grow" a 1000% for all I care, and it wouldn't move the needle.
> Finally, there's the global south which is also growing. This is a huge market that they can sell to.
That depends highly on China and their allies. China may capture markets in Africa, but it is actively alienating most of Asia Pacific, minus perhaps Russia.
That is commercially significant and entitles TSMC to bragging rights and huge profits. But if China fails like Samsung, they're at no strategic disadvantage at all and the US technology embargo will have effectively failed to do anything.
China is in no position of "failing like Samsung", right now. At most, they may fail like Samsung did five years ago.
It would also mean that the sanctions worked.
They have spent significiant resources in hoovering as much information as possible from companies that have data of interest.
Cite: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_intellectual_pr...
But no one had ever beaten Intel in 50 years, until someone did.
There’s no monopoly on knowledge and I wouldn’t bet against the world’s second economy with its government directly financing a strategic sector.
Closest may be SMIC 7nm on multi patterning, which they cannot produce at scale and is still 2-3 generations behind TSMC [0]
Canon nanoimprint will not be available to China either.
[0] https://www.csis.org/analysis/contextualizing-national-secur...