this is an inappropriate response
It's a technical discussion. Asking for proof of a technical claim that confused me is correct, not rude.
Who decided that? When was this negotiated?
Reread your comments and ask yourself these questions.
I did, when I began by discussing technical aspects of an article about astronomy? I wish I could edit my first reply for better tone because it was difficult to write, but we're not allowed to edit comments here so the misunderstandings continue.
If you decide it's a technical discussion but no one else does, is it a technical discussion?
Why does your decision matter more than others'?