That's my point though. The web should never have been bastardised into making applications. We should have seen the desires of web2.0 and built an entirely new software stack purpose built for online applications.
It wasn't fit for applications then and it still isn't now. It's just we keep trying to convince ourselves it is because we're too locked into the web now to ever move past it.
I remember how big of a pain in the ass Windows distribution (alone) was in the 2000s with entire businesses like InstallShield built around it. Tack compatibility testing on top of that and a desktop app for a single OS because a massive effort. With the web you could just upload PHP and off to the race. That slowly evolved into what we had today via jquery and electron and friends but what won was distribution and ease of development, despite all the handwringing people do about frontend. The grass isn’t greener on the other side and hasn’t been for decades.
It’s not even remotely competitive anymore. My favorite example is GoldenLayout: it takes me less than a few hours to read the docs and implement a full blown tabbed and split screen interface using a third party library and combine it with any framework I want like React, Svelte, or just vanilla JS. Each desktop framework have their own solutions to the problem usually in the form of commercial components but even in the best case, they take lots more time to wire together.
The reason for Electron's popularity is because:
1. web developers are cheaper and easier to hire than people with desktop software development experience
2. Electron is cross platform
Point 2 is a compelling reason. But it's not like other cross platform toolkits haven't existed. They've just been left to languish because of point 1.
If companies only hire web developers then of course everyone is going to invest time into writing Electron apps and banging on about the benefits of web applications. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy.
I say this with experience having watched the tides turn, first hand, as a software developer.
There are more web developers because it was a lot easier, even before npm existed and frontend frameworks went out of control. That’d didn’t happen in a vacuum - Electron was really late on the scene as far as frontend tech goes. It was originally made to support an IDE and not regular business apps and still won.
I’m talking about the early to mid 90s of web development and you reply with a monitor released around 2000. That’s a completely different era.
> with 2300x1400 resolution and my experience was very negative.
That’s more an issue with OSs not doing scaling back then than it is a problem with desktop software.
You’d still have the same issue today if you run a super high resolution with zero scaling.
> There are more web developers because it was a lot easier
It’s has a lower barrier for entry but I wouldn’t call it easier.
> even before […] frontend frameworks went out of control.
So you’re basically agreeing with me then. The current state of affairs is out of control.
> Electron was really late on the scene as far as frontend tech goes. It was originally made to support an IDE and not regular business apps and still won.
Its origins doesn’t disprove my point. Lots of things start out as one thing and evolve into something else. That isn’t unique to the web nor Electron.
Lots of absolutely positioned buttons clipped by a resize, toolbars that didn't hide their buttons behind a menu when the window was too small, uncollapsible panels with minimum widths that exceeded the main content, and so on. Most of them were about as resizable as a water balloon when you smash it on the ground.
I can assure you that plenty of good software did exist. I know this because I wrote some of it ;)