Artificial scarcity is the only thing that allowed recording musicians, and continues to allow fine artists, to have any career at all.
Recordings completely change that and would absolutely have been a disaster without some kind of IP laws because people would’ve been competing against a now unlimited supply of recordings. That doesn’t mean we have the perfect balance of rules but we need something.
The history of the USA would be very, very different without a few rich manipulators controlling our culture.