Global emission at record highs as world continues to overspend on carbon budget
abc.net.au
abc.net.au
https://www.dcceew.gov.au/about/news/australias-greenhouse-g...
Would indicate a continuing drop......
The big question is how can the rest of the world - Africa, South America and large parts of Asia grow without emitting a lot. I don't think its possible without large amounts of technology transfer, and I am not sure if the "developed" world is going to do it.
So, it's quite likely that they will never exceed the USA.
but its cumulative emissions are 15% of the global share at ~15% of the world population.
This is quite meaningless because China has been the world's factory. Therefore, other countries have simply exported their carbon emissions to China.But, these metrics don't really compute how much of the infrastructure built in China is for export products. Eg, if a factory produces goods for both China and export, these metrics don't say that X% of the emissions from the factory's construction or from the workers driving to work or the roads to the factory are to be accounted as not for China.
But certainly, China's internal cumulative emissions are somewhat smaller than 15%.
Global emissions at record highs as world continues to overspend on 'carbon budget'
If these environmentalists didn't push to shut down the nuclear reactors, we would have more than enough energy. We should be set on using more energy, not less and there are plenty of ways to generate it other than burning carbon.
Even China nuclear’s biggest recent success has been fairly anemic. In 2022 they hit 417,800 / 8,388,600 = 5% despite rolling out more nuclear every year since 2008. Back in 2008 there where at 68,394 / 3,481,985 = 2% nuclear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China
Meanwhile PV Solar went from 75,256 in 2016 to parity with nuclear in 2022 417,700 GWh/year.
Wind was at parity with nuclear in 2012 (97,394 nuclear vs 95,978 wind) but by 2022 it was almost double nuclear at 824,000 GWh. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China
And that’s in a country with extremely low construction costs and little concern for environmental issues etc.
It's important to recognize that costs of nuclear in many countries are high because of the environmentalists. It's very easy to generate endless lawsuits, or convince your state/country to shut down perfectly safe reactors just because they are nuclear. This behavior just destroys the value prop. Look at the number of reactors California has shut down, and France's pledge to go from 70% to 50% nuclear by 2035. The environmentalists stage protest after protest, then when they succeed at getting some shutdown they say "oh look, they're not economically viable".
70% of the power generated in France was nuclear, but significantly less than 70% of the electricity used in France came from nuclear. They needed to import power in high demand periods and export it in low which at market rates was a large net loss, on top of this they couldn’t export enough so they needed to curtail generation which raised cost per kWh.
Other countries installing wind/solar impacts how much nuclear power France can export going forward. Even with the vast subsidies France was willing to supply it’s just hard to justify internally.
> It's important to recognize that costs of nuclear in many countries are high because of the environmentalists. It's very easy to generate endless lawsuits, or convince your state/country to shut down perfectly safe reactors just because they are nuclear. This behavior just destroys the value prop.
Things aren’t that simple. It’s a long and complicated history with different issues happening at different time periods in different countries.
Other countries aren’t like the US, and we ran into capacity factor issues with nuclear. The US stopped adding nuclear largely because increasing demand for electricity stalled out. EV’s might slowly push demand up, but battery backed PV is simply cheaper across most of the US.
Nuclear has been politically dead in France for over 20 years and only recently got a bit a traction (because there is no other choice anyway). In fact, most of the problem in France are due to German environmentalists that successfully imposed laws regarding electricity for the EU. Many of those laws were written purely to make EDF less competitive because otherwise nobody could compete with cheap nuclear energy.
The reason France export when electricity is cheap and import when it should be expensive is purely because of regulation. They are forced to sell a fixed amount at fixed low price. So realistically you better do it when the electricity is at the lowest point. In winter thanks to Germany reliance on coal and because of their imposed regulation at Bruxelles they can sell their polluting electricity much cheaper than actual cost (without externalities from CO2). If EDF could compete fair and square it would be completely different.
And historically France has always been a net exporter of electricity, way before shitting on the CO2 released by coal was fashionable and way before renewable technology were half viable (they still aren't, no matter the propaganda).
From Wikipedia : " Since 1990, each year, France roughly exports 10% of its annual production. Its annual exchange sold has always remained positive.[7]
France was the leader in the export of electricity in 2008: 48 TWh followed by Paraguay 46 TWh and Canada 32 TWh.[41]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_France
And in French, they say in 2019 France was the first electricity exporter in the whole world: "La France était en 2020 le premier pays exportateur d’Europe, par son solde exportateur de 43,2 TWh, et en 2019 le premier pays exportateur au monde, effectuant 17,3 % des exportations mondiales."
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89lectricit%C3%A9_en_Franc...
You say things are not so simple, they are, you just want to make them complicated for political reasons. Nuclear is an extremely successful technology and without the fear mongering, massive regulation and anti-competitive behavior from Germany it would look even better.
Grids need to be balanced on a second by second basis so both importing an exporting power is a sign of a problem here. Exporting subsidized power is a net loss, and if everyone had significant nuclear then nobody would want to import it. Similarly, imports mean you lack sufficient domestic production thus if Germany goes nuclear suddenly France loses money and might face blackouts.
You really need to understand the underlying issues here. US nuclear power plants averaged between 90% and 93% every year from 2013 to 2021 without exporting or importing significant electricity. France has never gotten close to those numbers. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=51978
Demand is spiky, trying to add 1GW of nuclear in France would be useless if they are already curtailing nuclear power. Thus each additional reactor is useful for fewer hours a year. This means no they can’t avoid importing power, if they doubled the number of nuclear reactors they could do so but only at a truly ruinous costs.
Random French nuclear reactors capacity factor:
72.60% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belleville_Nuclear_Power_Plant
75.15% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blayais_Nuclear_Power_Plant
73.78% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cattenom_Nuclear_Power_Plant
71.6% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinon_Nuclear_Power_Plant
70.6% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chooz_Nuclear_Power_Plant
69.4% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cruas_Nuclear_Power_Plant
By comparison you see plenty of US reactors with lifetime capacity factors approaching 90%. It here’s a random selection:89.55% (lifetime) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braidwood_Nuclear_Generating_S...
88.45% (lifetime) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byron_Nuclear_Generating_Stati...
87.70% (lifetime) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Callaway_Nuclear_Generating_St...
88.40% (lifetime) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comanche_Peak_Nuclear_Power_Pl...
There’s some overlap between the most used French reactors and the least used US reactors but we aren’t exporting that power. Subsidizing energy that you then export is clearly a cost. They do this because getting some money per kWh generally beats turning them off.
And the comparison with the US proves exactly that it is ALL political. The US can run their reactor full tilt all the time because they only compete with themselves, it's just a different type of electrical generation business, and since nuclear is cheap once it is built, it is better to run it all the time and adjust the rest.
France does not have this luxury and is forced to participate and agree to bad deals for the EU electrical grid as a whole. Because the grid has to be balanced, technically and commercially, those are the parameters and those are what is used by regulators to favor different political factions... France could very well run its nuclear reactor to full capacity and export a shit ton of very cheap electricity, killing many competitors in the process but making decent amount of money that could be used for even more/better nuclear. This is EXACTLY what Germany complained about in the late 90s and this is why they have been putting a lot of regulation to favor their environmental bullshit even though nobody asks them to pay for all the coal they burn.
So, I don't understand how that could be an argument against nuclear, if anything, once you get the ball rolling energy is so cheap, others accuse you of cheating, just like Germany did.
I know, let me try and clarify the basics.
> France could export even more nuclear or be completely self reliant if it wasn’t forced by obtuse EU regulations to temper their electrical industry strength.
People only want so much electricity at any given instant so France can only export so much electricity at any given moment. This directly translates into capacity factor numbers because if nobody wants power they slow down production at nuclear power plants.
To simplify a 1GW nuclear reactor is selling at 10c/kWh on average a 85% capacity factor reactor is generating an extra ~120 million dollars worth of electricity per year over a 70% capacity factor nuclear reactor. That’s the difference between making 60$ million dollars per year and losing 60$ million dollars in the same year. Something like ~6 Billion dollars inflation adjusted over a reactors lifetime aka serious money. It doesn’t matter if nuclear is relatively cheap per hypothetical kWh if nobody wants those kWh then they are worth nothing.
Thus adding more nuclear in France means lower capacity factors and losing more money.
If Germany would be subjected to actual regulation on their coal usage during the winter and actually would pay the real cost with externalities then electricity would get more expensive, making the French nuclear way more interesting. French nuclear looks expensive only because of usage of "cheap" coal and natural gas by neighbors, and while everybody is pointing various nuclear cost that may come in the future, we are already paying the price of burning those fossil fuels. In the winter, French electricity is already 30e/MW cheaper; and that is before true cost is taken into account.
Germany is supposedly generating up to 60% of their electricity with wind (solar isn't meaningful in the winter) but that is largely dependent on the weather. One day they are generating over 30GW of electricity with wind but then other days they are barely hitting the 10GW mark. In the past month, Germany has imported over 1.4GW of electricity from France. In the past 5 years, their wind/renewable share of the total generation has barely gained 4% while their coal/gas usage hasn't moved at all (and Germany do not heat a lot of homes with electricity so that's even worse) As it is the share of renewable in Germany in a winter month is just hitting the 40% share mark. They have over 60GW of wind capacity installed, to be viable in the winter without relying on coal/gas or nuclear energy imports they would need at least 5 times this capacity.
You should read about "Energiewende" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energiewende You can see that in 2016 there were some complaints that this political "project" had cost at least 160 billion in the past 5 years, and electricity price in Germany were too high. German citizens are still paying more for their electricity and they had to subvention their green energy even more (while hypocritically burning as much coal as they did 10 years ago).
If we would regulate Germany's coal/gaz usage then French nuclear energy could be making quite a bit of money, just by running the current reactors to their full capacity. But that's hardly possible because Germany is running the show in Bruxelles and it is always about Germany's interest first. Which is exactly what I am saying: the current economics of French nuclear are not representative of what could be possible, first because nuclear was very unpopular even in France in the past 20 years (only recently gained traction because energy bills inflated and people understood the stakes) and secondly because Germany want to make everyone pay for their ideological choices...
I do agree that France itself do not need more reactors, but some will be built in the future to replace the aging ones.
Germany’s investment in solar looks dumb in isolation, especially installing panels in northern Germany. However, there was a real environmental argument to be made that subsidies between 2000 and 2015 were critical to drive down PV prices until the economies of worked out. Today I think Germany investing in nuclear over solar is a good idea.
However change has knock on effects. If Germany was producing say 40% of its electricity from Nuclear it would be less interested in importing electricity from France on nights and weekends. Thus France would be facing even lower capacity factors.
Southern France however is a much better location for Solar so it can ramp down nuclear slightly while Germany ramps up nuclear. Net result would be both countries and the environment being better off. http://newquayweather.com/solarpv/images/SolarGIS-Solar-map-...
PS: What’s actually going to happen is unfortunately going to be influenced by politics, etc and therefore sub optimal.
I do agree that Southern France can support some decent solar farms, but France is already investing in wind also. I think we have to use all the technologies as best as possible, but for now we will still need a guaranteed generation capacity.
I think we most likely agree on the technical problems but the thing is there is too much politics around all this...
Europe is heavily reliant on natural gas which is generally produced by Russia, (transacting through India or China ultimately does not change that).
Germany is happy to buy cheap electricity if it means saving money on coal. If importing at say 5c/kWh saves them money by using less coal then Germany would happily import at 4.5c/kWh. However, with nuclear they save less money shutting reactors down so they have less interest in importing power unless it’s really cheap as in 1c/kWh cheap.
This means if Germany adds nuclear reactors either France gets less money when exporting electricity per kWh, or France exports fewer kWh per year. Both of those are bad for France.
??