If a stock is trading at $100.00, and I put a buy order on the book at $0.01, how have I added liquidity?
> This may lead folks to believe that the liquidity is fleeting because they can cancel away before you can execute. However, that simply means they are better and faster than you, not that they are doing anything wrong.
The question is not whether it's right or wrong, but whether it is beneficial. I don't buy that HFT is intrinsically evil, but there seems to be little convincing evidence that it's actually beneficial, either. The system as you've described it basically involves scraping pennies off transactions that would have occurred anyway. That's not intrinsically evil, but it doesn't seem to actually benefit anyone except the HF trader.
> Why, then, don't we simply require them to rest their orders for a longer period of time? Simple: you want tight spreads. As spreads shrink market making becomes less profitable. When market making is less profitable market makers have to be more risk averse to avoid getting adversely selected and losing money. More intelligent models (they become more informed) and less latency (they can leverage that informedness to avoid being selected) is how market makers stay profitable in a market where the average spread is 1 penny.
What's missing here is an explanation of why we should build a system that enables HFT to be profitable. That's not something I care about. If lower profits for HFT means a better market overall, that's fine with me.
Frankly, in markets where the spread is 1 penny, it seems like there's enough liquidity already.