Are you under the impression that you're assigning homework to students? This comes off as really rude.
And no, I'm not going to write up a treatise on HFT for you. I don't pretend that this is an area of expertise for me. FTA:
Most HFTs run a market making strategy. What this means is they play both sides of the table - they take no position on whether a stock will go up or down. Instead, they try to offer securities both to buy and sell. If you want to buy, they will sell to you at $20.10. If you want to sell, they’ll buy from you at $20. As long as their buys and sells match don’t get too out of whack, the HFT will collect $0.10 = $20.10 - 20.00.
What is that if not "scraping pennies"? The entire goal is to jump between a buy and sell in order to skim a bit from the transaction.
e.g. Alice wants to sell at $10.00. Bob wants to buy at $10.05. They could simply trade with each other, but if Eve gets her way, Eve will buy from Alice at $10.00, and then sell to Bob for $10.05, making $0.05 on each share that would otherwise have gone to Alice.
Engaging in this is not evil, but I fail to see how it benefits anyone else.
> and why this strategy doesn't benefit the speculators the HFT is trading with?
Because when a HFT makes money, other parties involved make a little bit less. HFTs don't print money. They extract it from the market.
Also, because stock markets are not exclusively limited to speculators and HFTs.