Which is why the Oracle position is so strange and precarious: they're basically arguing that GPL users of the JDK source have a free license to do things (i.e. make incompatible versions) that people who didn't accept any license to any code ... don't. It's weird. What parts of that clear license to the public are severable from the source distribution?
Well, that's what a license gives you: the right to use something in ways people without the license can't.
Dalvik isn't distributed under the GPL, so I don't think any rights derived from the GPL distribution of Java can be used.
See why this is so weird? Oracle is arguing something that if taken to its logical conclusion would invalidate the case. So they can't argue it too far: Dalvik's success (in the market sense) has to be derived from Oracle's IP, but not so much to as to be a derived work (in the copyright sense) of the Java code. That's an awfully fine line.
Sun's objection to Microsoft's JVM was not that they implemented it, but that they implemented something which was clearly not Java (due to incompatibilities/incompleteness/etc.), but which Microsoft called "Java" anyway. At the time, Sun made no claim whatsoever (that I'm aware of) that third parties could not legally implement JVMs.
Oracle is now making the claim that third parties cannot implement their own JVMs without paying Oracle for a license, on grounds that copyright to a language or API specification extends to the right to forbid implementations of those specifications.
You seem to be implying that it's no big deal if it is proprietary. I disagree.