I've been top 1% and slightly below 1% at peak in video games that have milions of gamers and I wouldnt say that top 5% is filled with "truly talented people"
Top 5% is just decent people, but they are very, very, very far from top 0.1, 0.5%, etc.
At 1% I've been faaaaar from 0.5%, 0.1% people.
Sometimes, the .001% have simply found their particular niche in the ecosystem
What's the server population like these days?
What is your load out? I was a Jet main.
As I said, I'm a tanker. I run smoke screen, thermal camo, and LMG. It's an insanely fun play style because everyone relies on their minimap and thermal optics and I'm basically a 70 ton ghost on the battlefield. It's crazy how easy it is to sneak up behind enemy armor or juke incoming shells because everyone is looking for a white blob or a red marker on their map.
Also, given I'm almost unspotable, aircraft tend to leave me alone unless i'm dealing with a pro jet pilot that's looking for me. Sometimes I will piss off the enemy team and by the 3rd strafing run I'm like 'wow bud, you really got nothing better to do with your day, huh?'
Imagine a country where only the top 64 surgeons get paid.
The skill distribution for surgeons is ~the same as the skill distribution for baseball. The reason surgeons get paid to work as professionals is because there is demand for people who can perform surgery.
Shocking how much better they were than me. Technically in the same league, but in terms of skill it wasn't even close. The top .1% really are something special in these types of cases. Pretty neat stuff.
This reminds me of the range of skills in Go (board game), from absolute beginner 30-20k (kyu) beginners, 19k-10k casual, 9k-1k amateur (me), then 1-7d advanced amateur (dan), then 1-9p (pro dan). Each few 'stones' of difference can typically squash or run circles around the other. So many orders of magnitude.
Anyway, point is, I was probably in the top ~1000 Counter-Strike players in North America in the early to mid aughts. But the gap between CAL-M and CAL-I was just ridiculous -- we're talking about the gap between a college sports team and a pro team. The average CAL-M team wouldn't win a single match in a CAL-I season.
So, yeah - the gap is increasingly large the closer you get to the top of a given pursuit.