A pure university education without considering is this degree useful in the real world is a disservice to education. However a pure trade school education that teaches how to do something without understanding is not useful (I don't think any trade school is that pure: they tell you to ignore hard stuff but generally give you deep understanding of some important things)
Why?
> A pure university education without considering is this degree useful in the real world is a disservice to education.
I think this line of thinking is a much bigger disservice to higher education. It was very tiresome as an undergraduate to be surrounded by people that thought this way - and detrimental to everyone's education.
"I'll never use this knowledge" is the single worst thing you can say as a student, and it needs to be beaten out of undergrads' heads. Not encouraged.
Which is why the "I'm never going to use this, what a waste of time" feeling among American undergrad students is so common. If you fix the affordability problem and bring it back to where is was in the mid 70s (inflation adjusted) I think things would be a lot better.
That was true 50 years ago, but employers turned it into job training. My father in law retired a well off businessman with a History degree from Yale he got in the 50s. You know what a History degree from Yale qualifies you for today? Teaching History and maybe writing some books. The degree didn't change and Yale didn't change.
I'm not sure about this part... A very common pattern in my conversations with working class friends and family from my parents' generation is: "we were told that if we sent our kids to college, they'd have better lives than we did, but instead we all just ended up with more debt than we could handle".
It's tricky! If you tell teenagers and their parents the truth - this purely academic program will not train you for any job besides pure academia, which, while it can be a fantastic career, is a super risky hits business in which only a few will truly succeed - then that's only going to sound like a reasonable risk to take for wealthy families. But then you've badly limited your pool of academic researchers to this extremely small and honestly often not as promising set of rich kids.
Maybe one solution (which is not workable in the real world) would be: any academic program that does not have a viable "job training" component should only accept students on academic scholarship, regardless of their own means. If some neutral party thinks they are promising enough in that field to pay their way, they get to go for free, otherwise they don't get to go at all. The programs that do graduate people with directly marketable job skills could keep working the current mercenary way.
The reason this wouldn't work in reality is that the wealthy would still just game the scholarships in some way. Alas.
There is nothing wrong with art/music/history. If you are interested by all means take a lot of courses in them. You can learn a lot of valuable skills which is why good universities required a diverse background of "generals" that these (and many more) fit into. However they give far more degrees in these things than are needed. (even physics gets more degrees than the world needs - but most getting a physics degree can better pivot to something else well paying).
If you want to know what a university will teach your kids, ask them. They'll even tell you without asking them - it was pretty obvious to me as a dumb high school kid on campus visits what the emphasis of one program or another was going to be.
If you are a working class family with a kid who is very talented at math, and you go sit down with the counselors and ask them: If my child studies pure theoretical math, will that open them up to a life full of possibilities? they will say "yes, it absolutely will". But that's not true. It might be true, but it's a big risk. It's a risk a wealthy family can very easily absorb. But if this child from this working class family takes on this risk using student debt, it might go poorly. They might very well be good at pure math but not be good enough to go into academia. Then they might be unsure what else they can do with that degree, unable to get their foot in the door at the kinds of employers where just a general proof-of-being-smart degree is enough. And now they have debt and uncertainty about what to do.
It also might work out great! But it's a risk. And I know a number of people who feel they ended up on the wrong side of that risk.
99% of what we all learn in college is a waste of time for us. But we all have a unique 1% that is vital to who we become. Over time I expect that 1% to become 0.1%, then 0.01%, and for that vitality to become ever more concentrated in that sliver.
Sure there are a few going to university just for the fun of it. However most are expecting a job. Thus universities should train and emphasize thinking in more specific areas.
> "I'll never use this knowledge" is the single worst thing you can say as a student, and it needs to be beaten out of undergrads' heads. Not encouraged.
This is tricky. I agree undergrads say this all the time when they are wrong but they don't know it. They have no clue what they will use and what they won't. This is something universities should figure out so they push people to avoid things they won't use. OTOH, a lot of what they are really teaching isn't the specific skill, but how to research and analyze data to find complex answers - it doesn't matter if you look at data from art or from science, what you are really learning is how to think and the specific knowledge gained is isn't important or the point (I think this is the point you were trying to make?).
Companies that offer the jobs are the ones that need to offer the job training.
> (I think this is the point you were trying to make?)
Not really, it's that university education is kind of meta/self serving (the goal is not to train X number of students to do Y jobs, it's to give every student at the institution what that institution defines to be an education).
But like you said, the fact this produces better workers is a second-order effect. It's not the goal of most institutions. But not all institutions; some define "well educated" to have lots of industry practicum, and if you want that, go study at those institutions.
My main point is that it's not a "disservice" to eschew practicum or industry training as an educational institution.
When institutions allow student to take degrees that society finds less valuable (art,music...) they are doing society a disservice by not producing what society needs. Now if the student is wealthy (not rich) enough to afford that the price then I don't care: I don't need to impose my values on anyone else. However most people in a university are not that wealthy (most are young) and so if the degree granted isn't valuable to society the university robbed that student.
1. what's wrong with a student pursuing their own personal goals? A person doesn't need to produce for society's sake.
2. despite that sentiment you hold, it's clear many people do value art and music. Maybe not in its pure form, but those artists do in fact fuel industries worth billions. Clearly "society" values something that requires such skills and thinking.
No. Companies love hiring higher-ed graduates because it removes a lot of cost and risk for them:
- hiring only people with degrees weeds out everyone unable to cope with a high-stress environment, for whatever reason - crucially, also including people who would normally be protected by ADA or its equivalent provisions in Europe.
- it weeds out people in relationships or with (young) children, which makes them easier to exploit and reduces the amount of unexpected time-off due to whatever bug is currently sweeping through kindergarten/school/whatever. Sure, eventually they will get into relationships and have children as they age, but looking at the age people start to have kids these days [0], that's a solid 5-10 years you can squeeze them for overtime.
- it saves companies a ridiculous amount of training. The old "tradespeople apprenticeship" way is very cost-intensive as you have to train them on virtually anything, not just stuff relevant to the job, e.g. using computers and common office software. Instead, the cost is picked up either by the taxpayer (in Europe) or by the students themselves in the form of college debt. The latter used to be reserved for high-paying jobs such as pilots who have to "work off" their training cost but got compensated really well, nowadays it's standard practice.
- it keeps the employee diversity relatively homogenous. There is a clear bias towards white and asian ethnicity in the US for higher ed [1], and among top-earning job, males still utterly dominate [2].
- related to the above, it also weeds out people from lower economic classes, although at least that trend has been seriously diminishing over the last decades [3].
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/08/04/upshot/up-bir...
[1] https://hechingerreport.org/proof-points-new-higher-ed-data-...
[2] https://www.bankrate.com/loans/student-loans/top-paying-coll...
[3] https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/05/22/a-risin...
And thus you destroyed you whole point: females dominate universities these days.
[1] https://www.stemwomen.com/women-in-stem-percentages-of-women...
Unfortunately many programs are not designed this way and learning the appropriate skills is left as an exercise to the student usually in a sink or swim approach. So some students come out with the meta skills that a university education is touted for and others do not.
I do agree that "I'll never use this knowledge" can be a miserable attitude to have or engage with - especially when it's just a proxy for "I'm not interested in learning, just in getting good grades" but the idea itself is valid.
Everyone will think differently. I've never truly be research-minded and there's very much a bunch of odd classes that felt like a waste of my money (something to consider as education gets more expensive). But I do agree that there should be a space to foster researchers and especially one to overall round out a student, even if that space is more niche. I just don't think that everyone needs to go far into debt for that experience if they just want job training.
So I too desire a more explicit divide than "research university vs. industry university" and wish there were some better trade schools focused on software (not 6 month boot-camps. Think of a condensed university program without requirements of electives and maybe less supporting classes). But no one seems to be protesting this much.
It is a good peek into the professional software world though!
Writing a thousand lines of bug free code isn't that hard, so the need for QA practices won't be apparent. Then you get the ten thousand line intern project and discover things are not always that easy. Then we throw you into a multi-million line project and good luck: you need a lot of that QA stuff to make it work.