This is neither my idea, nor is it peculiar in any way. It’s a term used to describe the agreement we all commit to in order to interact in a shared environment.
This is neither my idea, nor is it peculiar in any way. It’s a term used to describe the agreement we all commit to in order to interact in a shared environment.
I know what this is used for. It's still ill-named (you don't sign it, it would be a "de facto" instead), and still debatable a theory (which states that in an ideal, invented state of nature, without such a contract enforced by an authority, violence would be the natural relation between individuals).
There's more (especially since the times of Hobbes) to describe how societies have functioned/could/should function.
Social contract theory is not much more solid than the homo economicus one: it has its points, and its flaws.
Supply/demand is also a story/theory trying to model, imperfectly, a reality. Or several ones.
They are both largely contextual, open to critique, and have been. Just take the time to enlarge your horizon, it makes it much more enjoyable and satisfying.
None of this is my idea; your problem is with the strength of the argument, not with my "opinion".
It IS a recent theory in the face of human history (and even more prehistory).
Those people were NOT smarter than you are, or can be. You’re terribly limiting yourself and your capacity for understanding and growth thinking they were (it’s not about humility, but submission, there’s a nuance).
It's insanely hubristic to think I (or you) are going to casually outthink many many thousands of scholars over the course of hundreds of years in a series of HN comments. To even think you may know better, without even fully understanding what it is social contract theory is, puts you firmly on the wrong side of Dunning-Krueger.
So, you're going with the old "appeal to authority" approach then?
You might want to pick a different direction, as that doesn't really work around here. :)