https://www.editage.com/insights/a-look-at-sci-hubs-current-...
Edit -
Clockss is a backup of academic content, mirrored at 12 academic institutes around the world. It's built on existing tech and means that things like dois should still work (if I understand right, https://doi.org/10.4103/2315-7992.204679) .
They currently backup over 50M articles.
> note that arXiv alone is already ~50x bigger than clockss.
I'm sorry what's your measure of that? Arxiv is about 2-3M iirc and clockss is 50M.
Things disappear because no one is paying to keep them up, either directly in time or indirectly with money. The government cuts off projects all of the time causing them to disappear. Witness, for instance, how Henry the VIII cut off Catholic monasteries effectively destroying their archives. Even things sent to well-funded organizations like the US National Archives disappear in confusion.
So while I think you're right that places like arXiv make more sense, I don't think that they're automatically better.
And it's an interesting question whether distributed, open source versions have an advantage. Sure, people can clone repos, but there's often no main person who promises to keep the repo alive making it possible for everyone to just assume someone else will cache a copy.
This is a very complex problem at the deepest level.