Ask HN: What lo-tech do you use for kids to play music? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: What lo-tech do you use for kids to play music?

2 pointsflippinbits3 comments

Hi!

When I was a kid I often played my cassette player when I came home from school. It was simple technology, had no major traps and getting new content was fairly easy. This contributed a lot to my later interest in music.

I'd like for my kids to have the ability to have such an experience. Now, nowadays nothing gets released on cassette's, and they do already have some favorites. Also, me and my wife are quite vary of screens for them, especially portable screens like phones and tablets, so we do not give them full freedom on how and when to use them. The problem is, that nowadays music gets released on youtube, spotify etc. - apps, and to access it the most straight forward way is portable screens.

I have some ideas on how to approach, like a laptop with limited access, I've seen some dedicated hardware for this, etc. But mostly would like to ask you, as a way to get independent view on this and new ideas. How do your kids access music? Do you have any alternatives to screens? What works well and what not?

NOTE: my kids are 2 and 6 years old, english is not their primary language.

Dedicated mp3 players might work well for this. I (no kids) have been using a Sansa Clip with Rockbox for 10 years. It checks all the boxes you mentioned. I fear for the day it dies.

I've heard that newer Sansas aren't compatible with Rockbox, and the ones that are sell for ~$50 secondhand.

To make control easier, a locked down tablet? E.g. a Kindle Fire Kids is inexpensive (but hardware is on the lean side and you have to work hard to avoid the Amazon ecosystem trap).

nsuring a lo-tech and screen-free environment for your kids while still allowing them to enjoy music is a thoughtful approach. Here are some professional suggestions:

Kid-Friendly Music Players: Consider dedicated music players designed for children. These devices often come with pre-loaded songs, eliminating the need for screens. Some models even allow you to add your own music.

MP3 Players: Opt for simple MP3 players with controls that are easy for children to use. Load them with a curated selection of songs, allowing your kids to have a music library without the distractions of screens.

CD Players: Introduce your kids to the joy of using CD players. You can create custom playlists on CDs, making it a tangible and interactive experience for them.

Parental Controls on Devices: If you choose to use a laptop or tablet, implement strict parental controls. This allows you to limit access to specific apps or websites, ensuring a controlled and safe environment.

Music Subscription Services: Some music subscription services offer family plans that allow you to create kid-friendly profiles with curated content. Explore these options to tailor the music experience for your children.

Smart Speakers: Consider a smart speaker with voice controls. You can program it to play specific songs or playlists without the need for a screen.

Musical Instruments: Encourage your children to explore making music themselves. Simple instruments like xylophones or recorders can provide a hands-on and creative musical experience.

Radio: Introduce them to traditional radio. Tune in to child-friendly stations or programs that offer a mix of music suitable for their age.

By incorporating these alternatives, you can create a positive musical environment for your kids without relying on screens. Adjusting the options based on their age and preferences will ensure an engaging and developmentally appropriate experience.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com