Car makers are starting to strip out CarPlay as well because they can see the consumer wanting CarPlay to control everything and car companies don't want to give up control.
Car makers are starting to strip out CarPlay as well because they can see the consumer wanting CarPlay to control everything and car companies don't want to give up control.
I think the general sentiment is that no, in fact, touch screens are a bad UX for cars where you, the driver, are supposed to be looking at the road.
Someone could make perfect software that was tailored to my specific desires. I'd still want physical climate and media control buttons.
Between the scroll wheel on the dash and voice control, I feel my media control is better than any physical controls I've ever used.
As for climate control, I set it up once and I've never really touched it since (occasionally a passenger wants their side of the car a bit hotter/colder) -- I just don't see a need to adjust it.
You obviously live in the particular part of the world that these screens are designed for, no seasons and no temperature changes during the day.
Unfortunately the majority of the worlds population don't have this, and find it cooler in the morning and warm in the afternoon requiring a change of temperature.
In the winter I make use of the heated seats via voice control.
Love our Toyota. Loathe the Entune system that would have been awesome in 2003. For Christmas, I’m having that awful homegrown experience replaced with a proper CarPlay setup.
Why should they? The software world gave up complete control to Apple and Google. Look what that looks like for anyone in software not Apple or Google trying to reach a customer on their typical device:
- 30% taxation on everything
- no ability to deploy whatever, whenever
- strict, capricious review
- forced to use their payment rails, their user account rails
- no customer relationship
- no runtimes, no hot patches, no deploy whenever
- forced to jump through upgrade cycles on their schedule or get your app down-ranked
- you have to fight ads against your own product. Apple/Google make money on those ads.
- if you want to side-load, that's "scary" on Android and impossible on Apple
- if you want to deploy to the web, the web is a second class citizen
It's absurd and intensely unfair.Apple and Google won and locked down the American consumer. You can't easily access them without going through Apple/Google.
If car companies fall for this boondoggle, this is their future:
- 10% of sticker price of car paid to Apple/Google
- ads for other car companies in the dash
- radio subscription fees going to Apple/Google
- car telemetry and demographic data sold to competitors
- car telemetry and demographic data not given to car manufacturer to improve their systems
- reminders to service direct away from vendor/dealer centers
- insurance data and analytics plays go to Apple/Google
- "Fast Pass" systems live in the App Store now and run on Apple payment rails.
- Future in-vehicle billing goes to Apple/Google
- Future self-navigation / smart fleet solutions to Apple/Google
- ...
All the hard as hell work of making a car, and you don't get any of these future upsides. It goes to the dumb, unregulated and uncompetitive smart glass companies. Because they got there first and established a duopoly with tendrils a mile deep.Basically, I always think, "what's the worst I could do or extort from a company if I controlled them completely?" and then figure that's on Apple/Google's roadmap.
I can tell you the future. It's that legacy car companies will be merged, acquired, and reduced to a body style and brand logo with maybe 100 employees. Real competition is coming fast, there's no way they survive.