Given Microsoft's position, wouldn't it be best if they simply announced that the Lumia will be upgradable? If they want to win the "hearts and minds" of people, they should make the extra effort to allay any and all worries.
FWIW, WP8 is really quite different from WP7 -- as far as we know, it's based on the Windows 8 kernel, and will presumably have the same/similar Metro/WinRT app stack.
It might just be that the WP7 hardware spec (which is now 2-3 years old) just won't reliably run WP8.
History shows that backward compatibility guys usually win in MS. I would be really surprised if they decide to NOT support older devices.