I think I would challenge both of these points:
> First, they survive technological obsolescence. Consider how even reading a floppy disk is a huge pain in the ass for most people today.
Most paper hasn't survived technological obsolescence, because it hasn't survived at all. Nobody's keeping anything on floppies, everything's migrated as you say:
> but it has a migration cost, and perhaps some risk. It's not a freebie.
Nobody saying it's a freebie, but it's a heckuva lot cheaper than running massive physical warehouses and libraries and museums with security guards and fire suppression systems and everything. And no, there's virtually no risk when you're always keeping distributed backup copies. We use checksums and things to prevent data corruption.
> Second, they have historically been less ephemeral.
Again, no -- hard copies have historically been far more ephemeral. Remember what happened to the Library of Alexandria? Hard copies are susceptible to fire, war, economic disintegration, and so forth.
Digital copies can both have plenty of geographically distributed official backups made and maintained, and also be open to personal backups as well if desired.
Keeping hard copies around seems like far more expense for zero benefit -- at least for things that don't have sentimental/museum value.