Hacker News Reader

"The absence of an invisible hand is caused only when it is wiped away by the punching fist of the government"

I assume you have some evidence of this and it's not just based on ideology since that would make you a pseudo intellectual. You should pass that evidence on to economists, they've been looking for it everywhere.

View on HN

Well, I think my view is pretty rational, I don't see it based on ideology as such. It's more the other way around: because by studying economic history, and economy in general, I became convinced of the values of (personal) freedom. But, to give some evidence that a stable equilibrium can occur: In the times of history when the free market determined what money was (precious metals), prices remained stable, sometimes for centuries. But once a government starts to interfere with debasing the money by law until it has no intrinsic value anymore, and keep printing it (so the same amount of goods & services are chased by more and more currency units), you can't have actual price information anymore. It's like measuring a distance with a yard stick whose units increases logarithmically in time.

Sure, but there were a lot of other things that remained stable/stagnant as well as prices. Like most measurements of progress or quality of life.

Your view isn't irrational, but if it's not based on ideology and it's not based on evidence then what is it based on? (hint: its actually ideology, it just doesn't feel that way because it's not an insane belief and it's a popular one)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com