In a way, it’s a continuation of the mid-20th century conflict between mainstream Protestants (now their secular children), and Catholics/Evangelicals over public education.
In a way, it’s a continuation of the mid-20th century conflict between mainstream Protestants (now their secular children), and Catholics/Evangelicals over public education.
Your issue is that you disagree with a plurality of educators on what American values should be. That's fine, but it's much more boring than the false controversy you present instead, where a shadowy cartel of educators is twisting what would otherwise be a values-neutral school system. That system never existed, and was never intended to exist. Conservatives just 20 years ago would have recoiled from that sentiment.
I didn’t claim there was anything improper about it, I’m just describing the dynamic that exists. I will disagree with you about “consensus.” I think people who hold this particular ideology are in the minority. But they are dramatically overrepresented in the education and journalism fields.
This is wildly untrue. In fact there was a huge battle to introduce a more "American" civics vs British/Eurocentric history in the early 20th century that wasn't really resolved until World War II when (for better or worse) American patriotism completely invaded public school curriculum.
Most people until ... let's say 1950 ... learned virtually nothing about the Revolution, "manifest destiny", the Bill of Rights (largely untested in court), or any other number of US cultural "values" unless they went to college.
Public school was the three Rs and the trades.
(1) Horace Mann's own words, in which he defines "education" as meaning "much more than an ability to read, write, and keep common accounts" --- and goes on to list, at great length, civic and moral virtues.
(2) The deliberate effort at the turn of the century to use public education to inculcate American values & civic culture into immigrants.
At any rate, Rayiner and I agree about this premise. Further, if I'm wrong, I'm clearly not "wildly" wrong.