You don't have the legal standing to take the the seller to court and demand they comply with the terms of a license between them and the original developer of the GPL'ed code, even though you're technically a party to it as the release of the code benefits you.
Law is a funny thing.
Agreed it's the right thing to do, but if I write a GPL module which is later used in say, a Microsoft product, I don't have the desire, the time, or even the money to take them to court.
Bonus question - what exactly will you be gaining by spending your time on enforcing the GPL compliance rather than on something else (like coding)?
The GPL offers you a deal that you can accept or refuse, just like any other license. The terms are definitively more onerous than permissive OSS licenses, but that's it.
>nor does it "infect" anything.
Yes it does, which is part of the damn point. If you incorporate GPL'ed code into your app, your app is now subject to the same terms by default.I understand the visceral reaction to the word, but it's generally accepted that the GPL has a viral nature.
As RMS himself said:
The GPL's domain does not spread by proximity or contact, only by deliberate
inclusion of GPL-covered code in your program. It spreads like a spider plant,
not like a virus.
it's generally accepted that the GPL has a viral natureIt's generally accepted after the smear campaign by GPL haters, just like the "General Public Virus" expression and the "cancer" remarks by Ballmer. It's still a pejorative and, in my opinion, defamatory term.
>An infection implies invasion
A willful infection is still an infection. Whereby an invsasion is always unwanted. You can't willfully invade your own code, but you can willfully infect it - whether that be with other code, or licenses.But now we're getting into semantics..
Depends if it's hardware or software. If it's hardware, Customs gets involved. Software's harder, but the fact that there is a set of circumstances which make enforcement difficult do not make enforcement in general impossible, nor does it invalidate the concept behind the GPL.
> Bonus question - what exactly will you be gaining by spending your time on enforcing the GPL compliance rather than on something else (like coding)?
You'll be gaining GPL compliance. That's the point.