Sculptor sues Swedish glassmaker for €1M in test of EU 'bestseller clause'
theguardian.com
theguardian.com
There's probably more cases where companies are selling furniture that steals/is based on/plays homage to other work by designers that didn't get a penny:
https://www.latwist.immo/5-design-icons-for-your-living-room...
Even so, the sculptor's greed here is stunning. She want to loot _decades_ of royalties.
“A major change in the Swedish copyright law in 1961 meant that works of applied arts have since enjoyed the same copyright protection as other works, today lasting for 70 years after the death of the author,” said Katarina Renman Claesson, a lawyer for KRO who is advising Wolff’s lawsuit.
“Yet even though Ann Wolff signed her contract with Kosta Boda in 1972, the company argues that the pre-1960 law applies in this case.”
"Loot" is rather strong when she is seeking a low (in terms of royalties enjoyed by others) sum of €1m from a company with a yearly turnover of €806m in 2022.The article is pretty explicit that her intent is to use the new law to rewrite the original agreement:
> It wasn’t until Wolff read about a change in Swedish copyright law at the start of this year that she came up with the idea of approaching the manufacturer about retrospective pay for her design.
>"Loot" is rather strong when she is seeking a low (in terms of royalties enjoyed by others) sum of €1m
Which candle holder designers are taking in royalties that make €1m look "low"?
Which glass designers are taking in royalties that make €1m look "low"?
The answer, contained within the article is:
According to her lawyer’s estimates, the sculptor would have earned between 10m and 15m krona if she had continued to received 2% in royalties on every one of the 15m snowball lanterns sold, which would still have been a relatively low cut by contemporary standards.
Ergo: Any contemporay designer of a long standing popular item who receives a contemporary cut.Kosta Boda glass is collectable (to some) and popular items turn quite a profit.
They made a contract. All parties adhered to the terms. Nobody was cheated. Now 50 years later, it turns out your the villain and please pay 50 million. Ridiculous
> “Yet even though Ann Wolff signed her contract with Kosta Boda in 1972, the company argues that the pre-1960 law applies in this case.”