Hacker News Reader

Medicine we have now is orders of magnitude better than what indigenous people could ever dream of.

GP was not talking about herbal remedies. Many modern medicines are derived from or inspired by plants.

https://www.thoughtco.com/drugs-and-medicine-made-from-plant...

He specifically mentioned dwindling indigenous people and their somehow unique knowledge.

The plant derived medicines come from plants known to indigenous people to have activity. If there's no indigenous knowledge available there's no way to study the plants and make modern medicines.

Of course you can still study plants and make medicines. That's exactly what your indigenous people supposedly did in the past, didn't they?

And if they did it then there's absolutely no reason to think that modern pharma can't produce the same knowledge. And the whole assumption that there is a body of invaluable knowledge somewhere, held by indigenous people but somehow unavailable to modern science is very strange.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com