Then you have to take into account that you the US doesn’t have a national high school curriculum, so the first 2 years of undergrad are essentially just getting everyone in the same page.
You’d likely be looking at a 6-7 year program with a much higher failure rate. It’s not a clear cut win and it would take a huge amount of coordination and effort.
They don't have 7 years long programs.
But you’re forgetting the part where the US doesn’t have a national high school curriculum. So a direct high school to medschool pipeline in the US would definitely include a year or 2 of general education.
However, what I or you think is irrelevant. America in general has decided that general education is a requirement for anyone who is college educated.
Every undergraduate professional degree requires general education. Pharmacists, accountants, engineers, teachers, actuaries etc...
With doctors, unnecessary additional years hurt them more then others and also it makes whole medical system more expensive. So yes, there is a difference. The situation is worst with doctors.
All of the other profession degrees provide public services and so pass the costs of general education directly to the public. In many cases like with pharmacists and physical therapists, it’s directly affecting the medical system.
Also take a look at the percentage of medical costs that go to doctors. It’s a small percentage. Speeding their training up by 2 years isn’t going to make much of a dent.
In fact if you move to 6 year med school it might actuality make their education more expensive overall because med school is much more expensive per year than an undergraduate degree.
We don't do that in the United States for any other undergraduate professional degrees. Engineers, accountants, pharmacists, nurses, teachers etc... all require college level general education.
Eliminating that is not realistic.
It is really not that it would be impossible, it is just that you don't want to change the status quo.
High school English isn’t generally equivalent to college English. High school history isn’t equivalent etc…
General education for doctors also includes calc based physics, so you need calculus as well.
Do you think people want to go to a doctor that has a less broad education than their accountant so they can save 3% on their medical bills?
Why don’t we do an experiment? A new medical classification—MDWL (medical doctor without letters). MDWLs go directly out of high school to a 6 year med school where all the fluff has been cut out. No history, no general chemistry, biology, physics, calculus, English, art history, political science, literature, sociology, psychology, foreign language, business etc…
Then let people choose whether they want to save $10 on an office visit to go the MDWL.
Physicians salaries btw represent about 8% of medical costs. So even if we did manage to cut medical education from 8 to 6 years we’re talking maybe saving 2%. That 2% would be eaten up by rising administrative costs, and most of those the cost savings would likely be taken by private equity. Not passed on to the consumer.
A couple of countries I know about¹ start off with a much larger set of students expecting a large. number will drop out early. You still need high points from high school, but it might be a better solution than just the top of the top grades.
¹ Thirty years ago. I am old.
I think it’s better to have discrete units:
1. you have more people who just never make it into med school but still have an accredited undergraduate degree vs more people failing out of med school after taking out loans.
2. You don’t need to know you want to be a doctor at 16 or 17 years old.
3. Med school is much more expensive than undergrad on average, so even if it takes longer, it’s still likely going to be cheaper. Sure med schools could make the first few years cheaper, but they won’t unless forced.
4. It makes it more likely that doctors socialize with non-doctors and get a chance to pursue non-medical interests. One of the biggest complaints about doctors is that they lack empathy—taking people directly from high school and ensuring that they pretty much only socialize with other doctors for 8-10 years definitely isn’t going to help that.
https://www.collegexpress.com/interests/health-medicine/blog...