Navalny Found in Arctic Prison After 3-Week Disappearance
themoscowtimes.com
themoscowtimes.com
True acts of bravery are done in the service of others, martyrdom is a pointless waste of human life.
He made a courageous and respectable move. The ball is now in the court of the Russian citizens on whether they want to fight for justice.
EDIT: of course most people don't control what gets passed for patriotism
Socrates
Joan of Arc
John Brown
Maximilian Kolbe
Folke Bernadotte
Malcolm X
Martin Luther King Jr.
Each made the World a better place; each placed their work above their freedom, their safety, their life.
It's more about their willingness to risk injury to accomplish some goal.
It's a recurring motif in Unsong (https://unsongbook.com/) which gets linked here occasionally. I haven't been able to get it out of my head since I read it.
I’d rather be alive and unimprisoned. It’s not brave to get murdered or jailed. You can’t do the work from jail, Solzhenitsyn notwithstanding.
I can’t believe Navalny went back to Russia, given the situation. They’d already poisoned him in Russia. Sure, maybe the FSB hits him with novichok in Germany anyway, but flying straight back into the lion’s mouth makes no sense.
I think it was a strategic error, not bravery.
Presumably they threatened his family.
However, it's not like I would still go back given Putin's record on promises ...
It worked for Jesus.
If anything it is very "conspiracy" alike that he arrived in Russia just before Putin made his last critical mistake invading Ukraine.
Nelson Mandela spent almost 30 years of his life in prison, a huge percentage of his life, practicing civil disobedience to affect change. Navalny is likely to suffer a similar fate, and there’s no guarantee that he’ll affect change in Russia. Those two men are so inspiring because of their raw courage and equanimity, but that doesn’t mean that you have to have that to make some difference, society is upheld by people making small brave decisions every day; James C. Scott remarks in Two Cheers for Anarchism an exercise he calls “anarchist calisthenics” wherein you break small, insignificant rules so that you’re ready when you need to make the big decision in the name of humanity. Arendt’s term the “banality of evil” in reference to Eichmann’s trial in Israel is relevant here insofar that evil is often mundane and a result of falling in line, though I’m simplifying the argument a little.
What I’m reminded about today in the west with its challenges is that old Scott Alexander essay “I can tolerate anything but the outgroup”: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anythin...??
…what that essay reminds me of is the importance of local social participation, the vacuum of political discourse from the loss of the public square and third places, and the expansion of the ingroup and expulsion of the outgroup—you can really go through life nowadays avoiding any disagreement, even in college where exposure to challenging ideas is the whole point.
I typed this on my phone, so bear with me and my sloppy ideas, I just wanted to throw some interesting discussion in this thread.
Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html