Disappointing response. Don’t make generalizations or confuse explorative questions for broad naïveté.
The issue I take with your approach here is that you’re focused on making the other person feel wrong, on the wrong path and assuming they know nothing (implied: idiot) rather than exploring ideas and solutions to novel problems.
That’s a common pattern in the world (ad hominem), but it doesn’t do much in innovation circles or have much of a place in early stage innovation practice.
I have a fair amount of experience in ag, and ag insurance, but not predator collars.
I’m cool with being downvoted for having an unpopular idea but please be more conscious: not everyone would speak up to your behavior and it’s quite unnecessary. Try to attack what’s wrong with the idea not the person.
You are literally on here telling me that my ideas will never work. It’s a lot cliché and not just a little bit hilarious. Don’t do it. Haha.*
I’m ok being dumb when exploring ideas, and that’s actually ok. Or it should be. At least on HN.