I would understand the argument that the office doc file format should be public and understandable, but I don't see an argument that the program itself should be open.
I believe the argument that grandparent comment made was that "once your product has a commanding share of the market, it should be illegal, as it's clearly anticompetitive by that point"
Microsoft Office so obviously is not like the only way to install software on a computer that I can't help but think this isn't entirely good faith.