Neolithic high mountain settlers were doing complex livestock/farming activities
phys.org
phys.org
Why is that absurd? It seems reasonable to me that after a certain point in evolutionary history, technological sophistication has little to do with genetics and is a lot more about culture and intergenerational transfer of knowledge.
>Pretty clear the ice age wiped away people that were in some ways sophisticated.
The article is talking about humans living ~7000 years ago, which was a few thousand years after the end of the last ice age.
https://www.amazon.com/Against-Grain-History-Earliest-States...
I wonder the same things, but we can see the fact that development varies greatly among humans with the same intelligence potential. Today there are isolated societies with neolithic technology, and they have the same brains that people commenting on HN have.
Also, there are other examples. The alphabet was invented once, in Greece around 700 years ago. How could nobody else think of it? (One explanation comes from experiencing contemporary technological development - many things are obvious in hindsight.)
The Greeks did not invent the alphabet.
The Greeks would later borrow this alphabet, using the same letters and placing them in the same order, adding vowels to better suit their own language.
As an aside, “alphabet” is quite clearly named for the first two letters in the Phoenician abjad. Though the Greeks did take the same names for their first two letters as well.
According to who? Linguists call it the invention of the alphabet and think it highly significant. Why should I listen to your claim?
> As an aside, “alphabet” is quite clearly named for the first two letters in the Phoenician abjad. Though the Greeks did take the same names for their first two letters as well.
How do you know that? If the Greeks used the same first two letters, that still doesn't mean they didn't use those letters, and not they etymological ancestors, as the basis for their word.
Also, isn't alpha a vowel, and thus not in the abjad? Maybe the Greeks re-purposed alpha?
I’m not really sure what your argument is here. Linguists have basically defined “alphabet” to mean the symbols the Greeks used (by deciding to require symbols for vowels in an “alphabet”). That in no way means they think the Greeks are the inventors or even the main contributors to the overall concept. It’s just a starting point. Besides people usually just refer to the Phoenician abjad as the Phoenician alphabet. The fact that they didn’t use vowels didn’t mean it was less developed or anything. It just means it was adapted to the Phoenician language. Were Phoenician around today they could very well still have no symbols for vowels.
That said, I’ll let you choose for yourself how important you think this all is.
> Isn't alpha a vowel, and thus not in the abjad? Maybe the Greeks re-purposed alpha?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenician_alphabet
Look at the letter names in the section “Table of Letters”. Look familiar?
Why do you say that? I see you have a string of reasoning, but lots of people do. What are yours based on? Are you a linguist? Did you read a book? By who?
For one sentence, 'the alphabet was developed in 8th century BCE Greece' is a pretty good one.
but not sure What your point was here:
> The alphabet was invented once, in Greece around 700 years ago. How could nobody else think of it?
As there were other writing systems before.
That doesn't mean large scale hominid concentrations couldn't exist without domesticated grains (there's at least a few grainfree riverine cities), but they are exceptional.
It's totally possible to have similar genetics to modern humans and live primitively, we have extant population in the Amazon basin, Indian jungles, Africa, maybe other places as well. It almost, but not quite, feels like an echo of the Ancient Civilization trope.
Apropos, we find more indications of migration patterns through the ages, this one about Austronesian migration patterns and where their population originated from: https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/7000-year-old-civiliza...
This is well documented in Rianne Eisler’s seminal 1987 book “the chalice and the blade” and is also well described by the Strauss-Howe theory of the four turnings, etc. there’s plenty of documentation on this.
I think what frustrates people is when they’re confronted with this type of data because it’s so conflicts with Neoliberal historical views. This is why Howard Zinn had to write “a peoples history” and other such books. These demonstrably show that the contemporary, modern explanation of growth and prosperity is only written from the perspective of those who did the dominating. This is a trope at this point, We know “this the Victors write the history” yet even if we know this, we still completely ignore it.
Are you asking why I believe that narratives about history are more accurate than the most popular “Neo liberal history?”
If so, then, that’s not really my claim. My claim is that history as it is taught to children in America in both public education, and in the majority of private education does not teach the philosophies of indigenous populations or frankly, any other population that were dominated or are otherwise different than the culture for which it is being taught.
I think this is exceptionally common worldwide, so it’s not unique to America. British pupils are not taught about all of their atrocities that they committed worldwide had an equal measure, as they are taught about all of the benefits that the British brought to the world.
So it’s less of a function of malice or anything like this, as it is that people really don’t want to own their own history and deal with the implications of taking full responsibility for it.
This memetically reproduces over 12,000 years such that we’re stuck with predominantly unethical growth pattern. In fact, there are many other options, but because dominance has so dominated, its the only thing people can conceptualize as a way to deal with existential anxieties.
This is all discussed in the chalice and the blade, and basically every other anthropological record. Egalitarian groups will eventually be overrun and dominated by property focused “growth“ and domination based cultures.
This is why we have the “turnings “and the political cycle, etc. none of the historical writers writing about these types of things like Polibius looked prehistorically because they didn’t have the information to look prehistorically because Paleo biology and anthropology didn’t exist.
It was only after Claude Levi Strauss that the real shape of human prehistory comes into view.
Go read the books
This is a reflection of brevity for efficiency but bias has certainly played a part in it. I think that’s fading to the point of absurdity though. “Land acknowledgement” proclamations at US events being a case in point. Incorporating indigenous wisdom gets a lot of focus in my corner of the US relative to its practical value and traceable legitimacy. Critical views of history, from Zinn to The 1619 Project are by no means in short supply. This has so much influence and currency on historical interpretation today that the side effect of “history without presentism” seems exceptional these days. This consequence is deleterious rather than additive to the study of history, and far apart from the goal of emphasizing “untold histories”.
I would propose that what most consider “untold history” (leaving revisionist histories and counterfactuals aside) is really just a rabbit hole of fascinating nerdom rather than a conspiracy. For example, I think more people should appreciate details of North American industrialization in the 19th century. I fully recognize that most people don’t know the interesting details not because the knowledge is controlled by gatekeepers but because most people are just aren’t as interested in it as me. Should they be? Of course! But if you’re into history you’ll always be stunned by the things people don’t know that you imagine to be common knowledge (or be incensed that it’s not). People have lives though, and for most people living in the present, the past is deprioritized. It’s probably helped us as a species.
It is not by accident that these things are not taught, where I disagree is that it has not been intentionally biased. We know for a fact that it has been intentionally biased and the entire purpose of the daughters of the confederacy in their drive-through the south to rename schools and erect monuments, explicitly to maintain racist history is unambiguous.
The fact that this remains, albeit it is now being undone slowly, is exemplary of my point.
It is insufficient for these significant cultural points to be casually mentioned, as opposed to intentionally acknowledged such that we can make reparations. If your position is that these things do not have remaining cultural impacts well, I don’t know what else to tell you other than that’s incorrect and again is a function of the specificity for which this history is taught.
Ruby Bridges is still alive today and there are women living today who couldn’t vote. This wasn’t that long ago.
1) Are you saying people weren't primitive (and how is that defined) in the early Neolithic or, implied by your claim, the late Paleolithic; or that they weren't genetically identical; or both?
2) How does the OP support that claim? I don't see anything that addresses either issue, unless by 'primitive' you mean something on the level of Acheulean tools - handaxes, essentially stone axeheads held in the hand sans hafts or handles, used for ~1.5 million years until a few hundred thousand years ago. In that case, by the early Neolithic our ancestors had exceeded that for at least a couple hundred thousand years (conservatively, and depending on geography).
3) Most of all, why do people care? Why is there a minor movement to push the capabilities of prehistoric humans? What is the emotional investment here? Why bother to come up with mis/disinformation and spread it about these people (unless such behavior is so ingrained that people do it for any reason)?
I also wonder how that claim is made to fit the evidence: It seems very hard to claim that our lives and abilities haven't improved generally and significantly over the 7 million years since we divorced the chimpanzee taxa, though certainly there have been many years and millenia where we went backward for a short time (short relative to 7 million years - of course it's not always linear improvement, but that's a strawperson).
Also, is the theory part of the modern political attempt to reject the Enlightenment and anything associated with it? (Edit: I'm not trying to discuss that movement, just understand the context of these claims.)
> parallel, diverse evolution, sometimes with independent discovery of the same thing
Does anyone say otherwise? It seems unavoidable that, without modern global communication, many/all discoveries would be too isolated to be known globally.
> retrograde motion
Temporarily? Again, who says otherwise?
When I was a child (say, 50+ years ago), we were taught that agriculture was discovered once, in the Levant. This is no longer accepted: it was discovered at least three times (Levant, China, Meso-America), and it would not be surprising if future archeologists find more.
The traditional, still widely accepted view of human long history is that we went from hunter-gathers in small tribes to agriculture to larger communities to heirarchies of control to modernity. There are now (c.f. Graeber & Wengrow) some dissenting voices about this.
Thanks. I'll look them up.
> When I was a child (say, 50+ years ago), we were taught that ...
It's unfair, especially after you volunteered to inform me, to make you the spokesperson. However, to go on a tangent I am always a bit skeptical about my and others' memories of childhood education: First, it was long ago, and details and nuance tend to fade.
Also, there's the question of not what was taught, but what was understood at that age. I may have understood a very simplified story, and lacking intellectual tools, one biased by pre-existing drives and beliefs.
Think of the last time you tried to communicate something, especially with any detail or depth or nuance, to a 9 year old. Could you teach one about long history, in a way they'd understand and retain the details we're discussing? Just think of all the general contextual knowledge they'd need.
Years ago I did come across a childhood textbook (late elementary school, I'd guess) , and it was pretty good. I don't mean it represents all textbooks, but that it was good from my adult perspective - no surprise because it was written by adults, evaluated by adults, taught by adults, and no doubt they thought it was pretty good. But what I understood as a child is an very different matter.
In retrospect when I was in grade school I was being taught things that were about 10-30 years behind the times in terms of state of the art knowledge in their field. Which makes sense. I wouldn't expect an elementary school teacher to be up to date with the most recent knowledge coming out of academia on these topics.
As another example I remember being scoffed at by my teacher in 2nd grade by pointing out how it looked like the continents could fit together. Plate tectonics was known by that point but hadn't become ubiquitous knowledge. I don't remember when I was formally taught the concept of Pangea but it was later on.
Normally this question would be obnoxious, but hopefully it makes sense in the context (and in the context of HN): Looking at the issues raised in my GP post (to which you replied), why do you believe that?
My hypothesis is, I don't know and I doubt most other people know.
Why do I believe what exactly?
That this is what I was taught? The point I was raising was now there's an n=2. chiming in. I've learned to trust my childhood memories down to about age 6. I've been proven right close to 100% of the time I've had people challenging those memories. And I remember being taught the whole Fertile Crescent story. I could even tell you the teachers' names that taught it to me over the years, and have distinct memories of their classrooms.
That it makes sense that grade school teachers can be behind the times?
If that's what you mean it's because almost everyone is behind the times. And I don't expect a grade school teacher to be an expert in their "field". We're talking about an age range where teachers can even be somewhat fungible between subjects.
Further, anecdotal evidence from my life (including both as a child and as an adult) corroborates this.
The story revolving around the Levant *was* the generally accepted truth at the time among the larger population. It makes sense that this is what was being taught to grade schoolers.
But he was very good at explaining something he was passionate about to children. We learned about other things, is some ways it felt like some years of middle and high school were learning an expanded version of what he taught us. It took several years before I realized how fortunate we were to have that experience.
I think it's one of those things that are possible but not provable - agriculture might have exist 100K years ago. Same thing for writing - it was independently discovered "recently" - could it have been discovered many times in the last 300K years that we don't know about?
IIRC one of our genetic bottlenecks is from this time period so humanity barely survived as it is and the glaciers would have destroyed most evidence of human habitation, especially when it's in an open field ala agriculture. The stuff that survives was generally buried in a cave of some sort and protected from the elements so even if they had discovered agriculture, evidence of that fact would not have survived.
During the glacial period the sea level was also much lower than it is now, so all the settlements are now far underwater, if they existed at all.
See Doggerland, for example.
https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html
Answer: The idea of property which leads to agriculture arises consequent with the loss of megafauna. So a massive loss of available calories requires a complete reorganization of society in effect, and as those losses spread around the globe as humans also spread around the globe. Simultaneously you have to develop compensatory mechanisms for calories hence agriculture.
This regime makes more sense to me, especially when considering the supposed nutritional poverty that the earliest agricultural societies are said to have experienced. "I worked this land, the yield is... mine..?" leading to conflict which eventually necessitated state and thus defined property rights. And this then allowed for vertical hierarchical development as "old money" was in possession of the most fertile land. I'll read through your paper here shortly, perhaps I'll find the answer.
This preceded agriculture.
I have an additional hypothesis that agriculture actually came out of having to feed livestock rather than trying to feed people directly
Do you have any reading that you'd suggest on the topic?
I think my theory fills in the section at the end i think on page 510 where they ask “how did we get stuck?”
Blood relations from Chris knight was uniquely important to my research though. The chalice and the blade though is a great if older foundation here
It is very much provable, the same way we've proven agriculture's existence in the last 10K years (I haven't seen the number 20K?). We find evidence. Despite lots of looking, nobody has found evidence.
Lots of things 'might' be true; that's exactly the issue science addresses. 'Might' is worthless; lead 'might' be transmutable into gold, disease might be caused by an imbalance of four humors that might exist, the stars might be campfires of dead ancestors.
Evidence is required, and that method works out to theories that stand the test of time - things that are true, not might be true.
The post starting this thread seems very confused about how long a few thousand years might be when compared to the several hundred thousand year history of just H. sapiens.
https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLOpJiy5R9WMWL7-8d0JpCp5...
The reason some people care (beyond purely academic interest) is that if those ancient civilizations did exist then one of the ways they might have been wiped out is by multiple bolide impacts around 12000 years ago. This is commonly known as the Younger Dryas impact hypothesis. If it happened to them then it could happen to us. I don't necessarily believe the hypothesis is correct but there is at least some data in geological formations and core samples to support it.
Why is evidence for that theory more difficult to find and date than evidence for the prevailing theories (which has been found, of course)?
How is this relevant to posted article? There were almost modern houses in Neolithic but that is long after ice age.
Later occupation of a site wouldn’t change much - substantially different eras are easy to identify by relative stratigraphy, and fires hot enough for metalworking can typically be loosely dated by their archaeomagnetic signatures.
Take a look online and you can find much written about it. Encyclopedia Britannica is often a good starting point, or the literature review in a scholarly article (via scholar.google.com).
Metal tools need to avoid oxidation as well which doesn't seem tractable over timelines greater than a few thousand years.
Stone tools were made mostly from flint due to the way it cleaves with sharp edges. Granite and other stone tools weren't used until the neolithic as ground stones.
In order to survive for that long, stone tools mostly just had to avoid moving water. Anything that fell into a river or ocean would be worn away quickly (like beach glass).
Unfortunately, until the end of the last glacial period (~12,000 years ago), the sea level was much lower than it is today and most human habitation has long since been flooded by the melting glaciers. Underwater archaeology is a new field that's growing in importance but it's slow going and the ocean is much more dynamic that dry land.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronze_Age#/media/File:Thutmos...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronze#/media/File:ALB_-_Hortf...
My POV:
Britannica article often are written by experts, sometimes the leaders in their fields (in the past they even had authors such as Albert Einstein). There's an editorial process to ensure accuracy by its formal meaning, the three C's: Correct, Complete, and Consistent. Also, the writing is often exceptional - sharp, expertly informed, with personality, like a top-notch professor. The downside is that the primary authors sometimes appear to have written decades ago (budget issues?) and then the articles were updated by editors. Also, while articles are internally consistent, Britannica is sometimes inconsistent between articles; for example, the article on hominids might say something slightly different about the evidence for primate evolution than the article on great apes; however, that is the case with every large reference work I've seen - you need to read a few articles if you want the comprehensive view, like talking to multiple professors about the same issue.
My view on Wikipedia comes from the foundation that, if the accuracy of some information is unknown, the information is worthless (a judgment backed by theory, though most people on the street disagree these days). I don't know the accuracy of Wikipedia information; I don't know which information in an article is correct and which is incorrect; I don't know which is complete and which omits essential details; I don't know when it's consistent or inconsistent. I have experience editing Wikipedia and that supports my POV; also, when I've chased down citations for claims, they often have been completely falsified (the citation says nothing of the sort) or are misleading. In other words, I think Wikipedia is the epitome of online misinformation. Most disagree, I know; my guess is that they don't want to lose their treasured resource and habits.
Wars can be fought between people who prefer the one over the other. ;-)
How does the scientific process factor in, according to you?
> How does the scientific process factor in, according to you?
Do you mean, how do I reconcile my idea with the scientific process, which is "a process ... that leads to eventual correctness" (if successful)?
Scientists don't say, 'this theory is 100% accurate". They say: 'Here's my claim; others say differently about X, and I disagree because Y. ... And in conclusion, here's where we are: we know this, what we don't know that, we should next look here and also there.' Their work is process, not product; they say, 'this paper is one step in the process.'
Wikipedia can't say those things; due to its process, it lacks an expert mind to look at itself (maybe an AI some day!). Wikipedia is a product (even if also a process); it says: 'This page is accurate', or at least 'you should use the information on this page as if it's accurate'. It doesn't know how accurate the page is, or how accurate different parts of the page are. You don't know either; any part could be nonsense, could be true, could be misleading; omissions could mislead badly. Information with unknown accuracy is useless. (Edit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38813185 )
Nobody seems to want to think about that. Talking about accuracy disturbs the head-in-the-sand safety people have found in the post-truth moment. Undermining Wikipedia does the same; they don't want to think about it. "If you want to tell people the truth, make them laugh, otherwise they'll kill you." I need to make it funny.