Doesn't this get a bit infinite-set? Do you need a specific bill to allow you to sue a police officer who arrests you for doing anything else that is allowed in the Constitution?
Doesn't this get a bit infinite-set? Do you need a specific bill to allow you to sue a police officer who arrests you for doing anything else that is allowed in the Constitution?
Laws don't exist in a vacuum devoid of everything but reason. They are crafted to encourage or discourage the norm. If you point a camera at a cop, he will tell you to put it away. If you don't, you will likely be arrested. For what? For being disorderly, since you're not following his instruction.
Now, is the prosecutor going to pursue it? No, because as you said, the law clearly states you can do that. But guess what? Your ass just spent the weekend in jail. And no, you won't be compensated for it.
This law creates a strong dis-incentive for the police officer to do that to you. I only wish similar laws were introduced in my home state of New Jersey.
Here is a fine example from my state: http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/04/people_arrested_on_...
Read a bit below the Supreme Court decision. This man was abused, arrested, strip searched, and thrown in jail ... because the police officer thought he didn't pay some fine, when he in fact paid it.
However, one could also argue that this is bad for victims, since the officer's pockets will almost always be shallower than the municipality's. However, if this law were to pass, a smart attorney would probably file a suit against both the municipality and the officer.
These ideas tend to come with unintended consequences.
Throw in the culture of the police corps - and you could see a lot more "not my job" type behavior from the police. This sort of law could very well be interpreted as a slap by an ungrateful populace.
I'm just saying there is a balance here. Us vs. them isn't likely to result in improvement. This law seems very knee-jerky to me.
I can't imagine how terrible that must be.
That's why the law allows officers to be reimbursed by the department if they lose a lawsuit, provided that they were following appropriate guidelines. I think that's a very nice compromise, targeting both the officer and the municipality.
For Constitutional issues, I imagine it depends on whether you're suing the individual personally or the state agency, and lots of other things.
As really helpful context, take a quick look through Glik v. Cunniffe, which held that there's a First Amendment right to record police, and that police in the First Circuit are liable for money damages if they arrest someone for recording.[1] Seriously, take a look, it's a great statement of what the Constitution is all about -- the First Amendment stuff starts on page 8.
The background is that police officers are ordinarily not liable for harm committed in the course of doing their job. This is called "qualified immunity," and without it you'd be crazy to be a police officer. But it's "qualified" because they are liable if they violate a "clearly established" right. Under Federal law, if they do that you can sue them for damages.[2]
What Glik held is that the right to record police officers is a clearly established First Amendment right. That means anyone who gets arrested for recording police officers has their clearly established constitutional rights violated, and can sue.
This is probably (hopefully) true anywhere in the country. But so far it's only been tested in the First Circuit and a handful of other courts. What Connecticut is doing here is basically preemptively recognizing the right without the need for a test case in their jurisdiction. It's a very cool move.
(On the other hand, if they don't pass this law, that doesn't mean you can't sue police officers who arrest you for recording. Seriously, read Glik.)
[1] http://www.righttorecord.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/10-1... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_1983#As_Later_Amended_a...
Of course any police officer that can't think of a dozen things to arrest someone for - probably wouldn't be on the street anyway!