Why does selection one get randomized if you say selection two is better, but then jump back to the original sequential if you say selection one is better again? That behavior felt bizarre.
Definitely looking into seeing if I can come up with something better though! The problem is making sure that whatever algorithm is picked remains as close to O(n log n) as possible. Randomising options in a way that makes require a lot more comparisons would be far worse.
For the algorithm, but not for the people taking time to do the rankings. Which do you want to prioritize?