While I don't disagree with his conclusion about the advantages of conventional notation -- I kept thinking about Iverson's Notation as a tool of Thought as I watched the video -- I do think that tracker notation might be roughly equivalent to conventional notation as a way of thinking about music.
It just that tracker notation isn't optimized for tonal harmony (aka the music of dead German men) and staff notation is.
Instead tracker notation is optimized for precision and machine reproduction.
Tracker notation directly facilitates complex musical composition by an individual, performance by an individual, and mass dissemination of those compositions.
Essentially, Tantacrul's argument is premised on the necessity of paper and meatware performance. Don't misunderstand me, I think MuseScore is awesome and recently I've found composing in staff notation valuable and efficient. This is just a critique of his essay.
And perhaps a deeper criticism is that his assumption of tonal harmony and paper and meatspace may reflect the kind of bias about the nature of music he criticizes elsewhere. I mean trackers are a "folk art" technology. They are a very plain and intellectually accessible way of notating music.
The verbosity of tracker notation means a person can gain competence in a matter of hours rather than years. Tracker notation removes the social gatekeeping that accompanies traditional western music education (that criticism isn't wrong). I mean staff notation puts tonal harmony at the center of composition. Percussion and microtones get short shrift...nevermind samples and noise and effects (what is the musical notation for a dotted quarter note delay?).
None of this means I didn't enjoy the video.
And none of it means I want to have an argument.
Notation as a tool of thought: https://www.jsoftware.com/papers/tot.htm