And at any rate, a country banning this tech will be missing the revolution. Protecting the buggy whip manufacturers and all that.
And at any rate, a country banning this tech will be missing the revolution. Protecting the buggy whip manufacturers and all that.
This is a very weak argument.
A pencil, an empty USB stick, an LLM without weights, and a small child can all be used to reproduce copyrighted works. A USB stick with a copy of a movie on it, an LLM trained on a book, and a human that has watched a Disney film can all actually infringe copyright.
There's an issue beyond copyright, though. A lot of companies seem to think it's okay to train LLMs on data that they at least have no moral rights to and possibly have no legal rights to either. (A TOS saying that anyone posting anything privately, IMO, does not mean that the person posting it had rights to it, nor do I believe that fine print ought to give anyone rights to anyone else's private information.) And a person that read all your email and an LLM that has been trained on all your email can both easily infringe your rights to privacy.
Speed and scale make these completely unrelated in my opinion.
I definitely agree with this, but I think a "good analogy" is really rare.
In this case, I think that the analogy just obscures the main point about copyright. I think the original comment would have been stronger by omitting the analogy and just discussing where the legal responsibility falls.
In almost every case an analogy is made, people discuss the validity of the analogy over the actual point of the comment (I'm guilty here too! my comment ended up being about the analogy rather than the main point).
While the ideals of freedom these brought may be desirable, we may want to avoid repeating the bloodshed from this particular bit of history. And that goes double for anyone in government who takes personal exception to being treated like French royalty.
Never mind that every regulation that constrains AI development in the West is a giftwrapped blessing to China and other actors that DGAF about copyright law.
You'll make friends on both sides of the political aisle with that position, but it's a shame to see it so readily accepted around here.
(Can't reply due to HN's rate limiting algorithm that penalizes me after four or five posts while allowing the most-corrosive trolls imaginable to party all day, so I edited to clarify.)
What?
The difference as far as copyright is concerned if one person has a scanner, camera, or blank cassette tape or everyone has them are the same.
If telling AI to study Spiderman and then output 10 pictures of Spiderman is illegal, how is that different from hiring 10,000 artists to study Spiderman, having them each do a drawing, and then hiring 100 talent judges to pick the top 10?
I think the more immediate issue with AI is that it's like having access to a close-to-zero cost human who doesn't care whether or not they're creating content which, if a human did it, would be considered a copyright infringement. And that they care so little about copyright (and other data rights) that they're basically incapable of even warning you if they are close to an existing character or living person.
I don't know how this is going to play out, but right now we're getting a more polite re-run of the luddites smashing early industrial equipment. I can sympathise with the loss of purpose and economic disenfranchisement, but the economic power in that revolution went to those that did the most automation, and I expect the same to be true this time.
Just because I drew Mickey Mouse doesn't mean I can sell it. Just because I sing Taylor's song doesn't mean I can upload it to Spotify.
Just because GPT can return an image doesn't mean I'm allowed to sell it.
Creation and distribution are different, and the reality is that the 90% of consumers will never create, they will consume distribution.
I find this a pretty week argument too. Does an LLM use a pencil? Can an LLM use a pencil? Does a pencil watch anime or read the NYT? Does a pencil create new work when upon request?
Are these things really comparable? Are they even related?