An opinion being minority has no reflection on whether or not it is correct. See hand washing in the medical profession before it was understood, or batch sizes in the automobile industry before Toyota ate the west's lunch.
> And I find it dishonest to phrase that as "The psychology portion isn't subjective".
You can find it dishonest if you wish, but I'm trying to point to a body of knowledge I can't adequately convey in an article or a hackernews comment. I'm not trying to pull one over on you, I promise. As I said in another response, this is a design decision. Most design decisions are based on first principles, a-priori knowledge, expertise, a wide range of studies and observations over time, etc. If a person can't write down (convincingly) all of the tacit knowledge required to make the same decision, they are not being dishonest.
I'll say it this way: We made this decision based on objective factors. I do not expect everyone to be able to see our decision or our reasons in the same objective light and I'm not going to try to convince someone that doesn't. But telling me it's purely subjective is gaslighting, and impugning my integrity over it is just rude.
> You'd be surprised.
No, I wouldn't. I would be surprised to see it on our team, or any other well-disciplined team. This article is a tiny (and frankly pedestrian) part of our overall development process. I'm sure you'd disagree with just about everything else that we do as well, and that's OK as well.
> Oh, really? Do you have an example?
Sure:
mail package version is decreased from 2.8.0 to 2.7.1
This happened when we were forced to pin to an older version of the mail gem because of a regression in 2.8.0.
Note that the scenario you described: "(1.1.2 can be released after 1.2.0, yes, but that's not a decrease even if something was backported)" isn't relevant to our practice. We don't maintain multiple major/minor versions at one time of any of our packages. If we did, they would be on separate branches as the version number can only exist in one place (the gemspec) and the same exact rules would apply. That is, it wouldn't be a version decrease, it would be an increase from 1.1.1 to 1.1.2 on the 1.1 branch.