Not going to argue further about it, though.
When I think about "magic" and "right from wrong", my first thought is this comic, because the exact opposite is a common trope. http://gunshowcomic.com/comics/20081015.gif
It is technology, not magic, which doesn't care about good and evil. The gun and the hammer can be used for good and evil equally, but "force lightning" was always used by the bad guys.
I don't think this is accurate. Merlin does good and bad things (I believe some bad being when he served Arthur's father), and Morgan does good and bad things. The Wikipedia article on Morgan le Fey even says "A significant aspect in many of Morgan's medieval and later iterations is the unpredictable duality of her nature, with potential for both good and evil."
Edited to add, also see this bit from the Wikipedia article on Lady of the Lake:
"In Le Morte d'Arthur, on the other hand, Nimue is still the one to trap Merlin, but Malory gives her a sympathetic reason: Merlin falls in love with her and will not leave her alone; Malory gives no indication that Nimue loves him back. Eventually, since she cannot free herself of him otherwise, she decides to trap him under rock and makes sure he cannot escape. She is tired of his sexual advances, and afraid of his power as "a devil's son", so she does not have much of a choice but to ultimately get rid of him."
Also Obi-wan and Vader may have supernatural powers but they act more like knights than wizards. Comparing them to Merlin and Morgan seems a bit of a stretch to me.
> Early appearances of Morgan in Arthurian literature do not elaborate her character beyond her role as a goddess, a fay, a witch, or a sorceress, generally benevolent and connected to Arthur as his magical saviour and protector.
So, migration to amorality was a later development.
> Also Obi-wan and Vader may have supernatural powers but they act more like knights than wizards.
Alright, if you want to say that because of their lightsaber combat. There's also Yoda and the Emperor, neither of whom use "swords" in the original series, they're totally dependent on their magic.
This claim isn't true insofar as historically Merlin and Morgan do both good and evil things. Now you seem to be moving the goal posts and claiming medieval isn't historical.
You can also look at Medea, who is helper/ healer to Jason and also a ruthless killer at many points in her life.
>>Alright, if you want to say that because of their lightsaber combat. There's also Yoda and the Emperor, neither of whom use "swords" in the original series, they're totally dependent on their magic.
Well, for one thing, they aren't using magic, they are using "the force." Now you can say it's just magic with a different name, but that's sort of like saying a exorcist or saint in the Christian tradition is doing magic. There's a fun bit in Good Omens about that:
--
“Occult forces?”
“You and me,” explained Crowley.
“I’m not occult,” said Aziraphale. “Angels aren’t occult. We’re ethereal.”
--
At any rate to me The Emperor seems more like a demon/ devil figure, and Yoga more like a saint, Buddha, or monk, than a wizard. Though I realize the distinction is in the eye of the beholder.
A sufficient number of grains of rice will satiate any given animal, regardless of its size.
They might not understand how it works, but the idea that it would be indistinguishable from magic upon close inspection to any but the close-minded and superstitious? Bah.
A Dyson Sphere wouldn't be magical to us, it would just been a super impressive feat of engineering. Learning about warp drives and teleporters would inform us that our understanding of physics is incomplete. But it wouldn't be magical, strictly speaking. We'd have some idea of how aliens had achieved both, and what sort of updates to physics would be needed. There's talk of looking for Type 3 Kardashev galactic civilizations, so we have an idea of what that thermodynamically would look like.
Only something like The Q on Star Trek would be sufficiently advanced, and there is no scientific explanation for Q. They're a god-like race that don't have to concern themselves with physical limits, because they're fictional. However sufficiently advanced any actual civilization is, they're still dealing with thermodynamics, Planck Scale limits and what not. We can already calculate maximum compute (by using a black hole). There's no reason to believe god-like aliens would be omniscient/omnipotent like Q.
Your point of view makes the same assumption that would have been made by almost anyone in the 18th century. Anything they would have imagined would have been based on things that existed or had some theoretical basis then, and they would have said that anything else was impossible. Just as you are doing now. Or even in the 19th century: "In 1889, Charles H. Duell was the Commissioner of US patent office. He is widely quoted as having stated that the patent office would soon need to shrink in size, and eventually close, because, according to his perspective: — Everything that can be invented has been invented." [1]
When I referred in my original comment to technology that may involve a deep understanding of awareness itself, phenomenon like Q may begin to come into scope. But again, we almost certainly can't even begin to imagine the things that will emerge because, today, we simply don't have any basis to make the necessary extrapolations.
[1] https://www.reorbit.space/news/everything-that-can-be-invent....
Clarke's quote isn't "seems like magic" though. It's "indistinguishable from magic." When the Iphone runs out of batteries it's not going to seem so magical, is it?