I think one issue we have is that authors of a paper shouldn’t be forced to provide “tech support” for life under the sword of retraction. I try to reimplement analysis and algorithms in the literature all the time, and it’s hard to get it right. I don’t want to write to the authors for help without trying my best first. And I don’t get to write to the editors complaining about no response unless I’m thoroughly convinced of an error.
That’s why I think the comment article triggering a real investigation is the right process. It showed that Mur put enough effort into his replication effort by thoroughly describing the process.
The final exchange with the authors was confusing to me, I don’t get what happened. But I do think Mur was right to be frustrated at that moment.