It failed because key stakeholders just wouldn’t read the memo and I couldn’t figure out a way to make it work. Sadly, there was no autocratic power forcing the process.
So it ended very frustratingly with people asking questions in the memo and asking for a summary presented to them.
The memos were really helpful for product design so I still use the technique but just as a design reference for building.
The whole point of the method is to address the premise that you cannot rely on people to read documents in advance.
Don’t think like an engineer with a few meetings and lots of prep time. Think like super busy people who have no prep time available. Or at least that your meeting isn’t a high enough priority to warrant them prepping.
If you wait until the beginning of the meeting to prepare, there is an extremely high risk that someone else in the room is prepared to eat your lunch. Don’t surrender the initiative by being lazy.
Fwiw I bet Bezos pre-reads plenty of memos and I doubt very much that his is lazy. The point stands.