If you don't like the cost assumptions (they cite sources) you can tweak them and see how the optimum solutions change.
If you don't like the cost assumptions (they cite sources) you can tweak them and see how the optimum solutions change.
The equivalent of Snowy 2 - 350 GWh in lithium ion batteries at current prices would be about $48 billion. The actual cost will be about $13 billion - ~3.7x cheaper.
I like that they use actual historical weather models though. I can't stand op-eds that assume that you wouldn't have a mix of solar and wind and short and long term storage to stabilize power output. It's the first model I've seen that's definitely on the right track.
Note I said solar plus batteries. Many of the ridiculous back of the envelope numbers you see for batteries assume every watt is sacred and must be stored and used.
It's usually cheaper to build more renewables, throw some over generation away and charge batteries for short term balancing when that is actually cheaper.
What you actually care about is electricity delivered and having weeks of storage isn't as valuable when you can rely on the sun rising every day.
Snowy 2 is a particularly bad project:
https://reneweconomy.com.au/snowy-2-much-how-can-a-2-2gw-wat...
but I'd suggest any hydro project where the dam isn't needed for other water based uses e.g. agricultural, is probably going to struggle to justify itself versus more renewables and batteries.
It's 3.7x cheaper with roughly equivalent ability to dispatch power and roughly similar round trip efficiency. I fail to see how that adds up to losing economically.
>What you actually care about is electricity delivered and having weeks of storage isn't as valuable
Snowy 2 isn't weeks. It's about ~4 hours. I agree that Australia doesn't need weeks worth of 90%-roundtrip-efficiency storage. About 8-12 hours is enough to achieve a 95% green grid.
>Snowy 2 is a particularly bad project:
Your article complains that the price is higher than it was advertised at which is true, but the new higher price "blowout" price tag of $12 billion still pegs it as 3.7x cheaper than batteries. For some reason your article chooses not to make this comparison, although it's keen to emphasize that 12 billion is 4k per family.
> The claimed 350,000MWh of storage has long been disputed by energy experts as not being deliverable:
> * The upper reservoir, Tantangara, is rarely full.
> * The lower reservoir, Talbingo, even if empty can only fit two-thirds of Tantangara’s water.
> * Talbingo is normally kept as full as possible as it also serves as the upper reservoir for the Tumut 3 pumped hydro station (1,800 MW).
> * Refilling Tantangara will take a couple of months due both to limited periods when pumping energy is cheap enough and to the limited inflow into Talbingo from Eucumbene Dam.
An article suggseting it can provide less than half, which already puts it nearly on par with just purely batteries:
https://theconversation.com/snowy-2-0-will-not-produce-nearl...
But you seem to have missed my main point that comparing the price of storing energy over longer than a day is silly if you can instead spend some of the money on solar power which can deliver power on a predictable schedule and reduce the need for storage.
Their claims don't make a lot of sense though.
>The upper reservoir, Tantangara, is rarely full.
So... it's a battery that doesn't get filled up. Cool I guess we need to produce more power so we can utilize it better? No. They want it shut down.
>The lower reservoir, Talbingo, even if empty can only fit two-thirds of Tantangara’s water.
And? It's simple physics - you push water uphill that stores power. Push it uphill again and you store even more power.
>Refilling Tantangara will take a couple of months due both to limited periods when pumping energy is cheap enough
"Oh no, we haven't built enough solar and wind yet to match the storage capacity of this enormous battery. Let's just stop building it!" wtf?
>An article suggseting it can provide less than half, which already puts it nearly on par with just purely batteries: https://theconversation.com/snowy-2-0-will-not-produce-nearl...
This article looks even more like bitterness from the competition and they seem similarly COMPLETELY INCAPABLE of comparing what they call a "blowout cost" to the cost of batteries. Probably because 3.7x still blows chemical batteries out of the water and they're acutely aware of that fact being inconvenient.
>But you seem to have missed my main point that comparing the price of storing energy over longer than a day is silly if you can instead spend some of the money on solar power which can deliver power on a predictable schedule
You seem to be saying that storage can be done away with. It can not.
You're putting a lot of effort into missing my point.
I can see that cost for the solar/wind itself but seems very low for the masses of hydrogen (and associated round trip losses) that it's suggesting. I have read some estimates that it could at least double the price?
A system that has a gas turbine backup for that non-windy week of winter that happens every 5 years is something of substantial value. Use batteries for capital maximizing daily cycles, and leave coal and gas as "storage" for seasonal emergency cycles, this would be a major, major achievement for humanity.
So this makes the battery and the gas plant compete in the market place, each with it's own economic strengths. The gas plant won't handle daily cycles since the emissions cost would kill it, but it can provide emergency power at a rate and for a duration that would make batteries monstrously capital expensive.
By slowly sliding up the emissions pricing, you will tradeoff the long term emissions versus the energy cost, and let the market efficiently allocate the resources until net zero, or near zero, becomes economically attainable.