If the Alexa/Echo-category of devices are meant to be some widely flexible and pervasively useful device from Star Trek, they're a failure.
If they're meant to be a usable $30 kitchen timer and music player, they're pretty great.
If they're meant to be a usable $30 kitchen timer and music player, they're pretty great.
Is that a story of failure or of success?
Starbucks launched to sell beans and espresso machines. YouTube launched as a video dating site. Are they also failures?
I think people see more than $30 of value in them, at least as their revealed preferences suggest.
(I'm deliberately excluding the "ten words to 'author' a holodeck scene" part, that had always been stretching my imagination a little too far, more "this can't work!" than space travel and transporter beams. Then stable diffusion happened)
I believe it is possible to have made it better, but they didn't try, they just gave up, like much of google products.