Flying circuses led to the first aerial maps of Earth
atlasobscura.com
atlasobscura.com
The more things change, the more they stay the same.
There's a 1785 entry in the betting book for Brooks's (a London gentlemen's club) that reads "Ld. Cholmondeley has given two guineas to Ld. Derby, to receive 500 Gs whenever his lordship fucks a woman in a Balloon one thousand yards from the Earth."
This was only two years after the first successful ballon ascent.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_military_ballooning
Looking at the other direction (balloons shot down), there were indeed quite a number of them over the WWI battlefields!
There are many places where the airstreams can be estimated fairly reliably, such as off the coast during certain hours of the day. An attacking army was able to setup hundreds of balloons on the deck of the boat, and then float over the city walls and drop flaming "bombs" from a height they leaves them untouchable. Or they could breach the walls of the city by floating over it and landing somewhere inside.
(In fact, in a Napoleonic siege - the attacker could setup rows of tethered balloons to heights that will allow them to rain arrows / bullets from the outside without caring about the winds, or the defenders could do the same to rain arrows / bullets on the besieger. Though not sure how often there have been sieges in the past two hundred years.)
Of course, there is the issue that they need a safe place to land, but in many cases that is solvable - for example, to attack an island, boats can fish them out on the other side, and in many city areas there is enough area to regroup either past the city walls, or inside the city in a sparser area.
And if one built fins, and the winds were low enough, one could actually create direction by flapping, which would be enough in some cases, etc.
And that is without further innovations that definitely have been worked out had there been a will.
I once heard it said that if the hot air balloons existed when the Romans beat the Greeks (as all the knowledge for it existed but not the application), the world would look different today.
There is a long history of all kind of military ballooning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_military_ballooning
> An attacking army was able to setup hundreds of balloons on the deck of the boat, and then float over the city walls and drop flaming "bombs" from a height they leaves them untouchable.
If you can park a boat near a city you can destroy it/harass it much easier with just cannons. It is not enough to show that a thing can achieve an effect, but you also have to show that no other thing can achieve a comparable or better effect.
> they could breach the walls of the city by floating over it and landing somewhere inside.
They can, but that sounds like a recipe to be cut off from your friends and be easy prey to the enemy. And that's if they are lucky and do not drift off target. Not sure if that is a good idea.
> attacker could setup rows of tethered balloons
I think you are under estimating the amount of support required per balloon. The French Aerostatic Corps during the battle of the Fleurus had one balloon, and they needed 20 man to carry it to position.
> And if one built fins, and the winds were low enough, one could actually create direction by flapping
Balloons are huge, and they act kind of like a sail. Even in dead calm air, which itself is very rare, you would not get anywhere by human powered flapping because you would need to overpower all the air resistance. You are worse even in the slightest breeze.
Murphy's first law of combat: if the enemy is in range so are you.
With cannons it's even worse, since the defender usually has a height advantage over a ship and thus has more range. And that's ignoring that you can put heavier cannons on city walls than you can put on ships.
Field artillery spotting was also a popular application in the 19th century.
https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/civil-war-balloo...
Even today, or maybe even more today, balloon flights are risky. Landing is difficult, at the best, lethal at the worst you might get burned to crisp in power cables, end up in ocean or a mountain wall. Thus, most balloons can only fly very predefined, tested, routes to avoid complications.
I stumbled upon it at a thrift store a while back.
Every turn of the 30 or so pages has a full color photo of a balloon being prepped, flown, or landed, accompanied by a short, large-print paragraph full of snark.
The opening:
"Hot air ballooning is using hot air in a bag to go up. Gravity brings you down. Every time. It's so much fun that many people only do it once. They get all the fun they need the first time..."
There's not much info about it on the internet, what little there is points to a newer 1993 reprint called "Hot Air: Launching, Floating High, and Landing".
https://openlibrary.org/works/OL14850023W/Full_of_hot_air?ed...
The text is the same, but the pictures are by a different photographer. Maybe I'll figure out how to submit my copy to Open Library this week.