Isn't pretty much all human art just regurgitation, recombination of prior art, audiovisual experience, emotions, human experience?
Isn't pretty much all human art just regurgitation, recombination of prior art, audiovisual experience, emotions, human experience?
For humans its impossible to create same art as someone elses. For LLMs its impossible to create anything else than copy of art thats in its database.
Even if you model yourself on someones work and try to replicate it the results will be different. Its not that artists want to always create work different from each other its actually impossible for them.
Saying that art is “just” recombination of prior art is extremely dehumanising. Its like saying are ideas are just recombination of the ideas before… ok so general theory of relativity is just recombination of caveman thinking about fire and finding out how to create it?
You forget that LLMs don't generate images out of its own volition. You need to prompt them. That's the injection of emotions, human experience, into the LLM. LLM provides technical means to create an image, the prompt author provides the idea behind the art, the composition, juxtaposition etc.
> Saying that art is “just” recombination of prior art is extremely dehumanising.
Based on your previous lines, you did notice that I mentioned "prior art, audiovisual experience, emotions, human experience", so I won't reply to that strawman.
Execution is the creative and hard part not thinking out the content of the artwork. Most artworks content is super basic like face of a person. Midjourney will make even the basic prompts look awesome.
I am sorry but you wont experience what artists do by prompting LLMs. We just stole, copied their work and possibly destroyed their lives. Shame.
But you're asserting that in case of AI training it's "stealing property", but imply it's not stealing for human learning. I think you need to substantiate this claim/difference. "Humans learn differently from AIs" is not enough.
Seems like its working on some people.
Right not with a high degree of confidence we can state that they are taking what’s not theirs, apply software to it, and resell it.
Everything else is their defence of said process, gaslighting people and spreading schizoid fear to obfuscate it.
I am surprised at the prevalence of building armies of strawmen here.
Better to call them out or not engage in discussion.
Swiping everything under strawman without explanation is not productive to the discussion.