China plans national, unified CPU architecture
extremetech.com
extremetech.com
This is such a stupid idea that it sounds like something out of a novel warning against the evils of big government.
Innovation comes from many competing ideas, not one idea to rule them all.
This does sound like one of the many boondoggles that governments oversee, but I'd say there's still a role for big government in this area, setting proper RAND-Z standards, busting cartels, supporting open source and the like.
Stagnant mature economy grows by innovation. How would you seek innovation in an economy that grows everywhere?
Another interesting choice is MIPS, which I'd also like to see rise as a 3rd alternative to ARM and x86, but I heard ARM, AMD and Google are considering buying MIPS.
I've heard the latest Loongson chips have support for executing 'some' x86 instructions in hardware, though, so perhaps practicality will beat purity after all.
Incidentally, I don't know why your recollection of complaints about China's atrocious human rights record skews towards the (rather few) complaints that are on HN about RMS' choice of laptop, or about the Apple/Foxconn dustup (which incidentally caught several other companies to a lesser extent), but it's not really germane to the conversation at hand.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Minutes_Hate
And as I said, I don't understand why China's human rights record is more germane to this particular conversation sub-thread. You could have replied at the top level to rail against China, but you replied instead to the apparently irresistible irony of someone wishing to have a chinese made laptop with Free Software rather than a chinese made laptop without. Which suggests to me at least that people may be struggling to cope with the idea that pretty much everything is made in China and would rather pretend that their non-longsoon CPU device is in some way morally superior.
They won't switch because their cost structure is higher than ARM's cost structure. Their whole company is used to selling expensive chips with a lot higher profit/chip. So they will not know how to sell these chips properly and be just as profitable.
They will also have a conflict of interest with x86. Adopting ARM means admitting defeat for x86, and their x86 business will go down that much faster - unless they intentionally slow down the ARM business, in which case, what's the point of trying to compete with ARM chips anyway?
This is why they failed with the Xscale ARM division, too. Intel can't sell dirt cheap processors that would make them billions per quarter, and they can't do it without hurting their x86 business. Why do you think Atom is their poorest brand ever and has stagnated so much? Because they never wanted it to become good enough for low-end laptops, and they only started working on energy efficiency much harder once they saw the ARM threat.
PS: I don't think Intel can maintain that advantage indefinitely, eventually when chips are designed by arranging individual atoms everyone will be on an even playing field. But, we are a long way from that point.
Probably historical inertial though.
"The primary reason for this move is to lessen China’s reliance on western intellectual property.
There are at least five existing ISAs on the table for consideration — MIPS, Alpha, ARM, Power, and the homegrown UPU — but the Chinese leadership has also mooted the idea of defining an entirely new architecture."
So it's going to avoid foreign IP by choosing a chip archecture 4/5 of which depend on foreign IP, or building one of it's own that (given the crazy world of IP) will almost certainly inspire lawsuits from the incumbents. That makes no sense.
If IP is the issue why not cut out the middle-man and just compulsory licence any patents that cover national standards? I'd heard that China was threatening to do this previously and it's an entirely sensible thing that every country should do even if would enrage the current monopolist cartels.
Have we really gone 20 years without a commercially significant new CPU ISA?
-- Ken Thompson - Reflections On Trusting Trust
I'm confused by these two sentences. $5 million is pocket change for a government, why would that cost for a license be putting China off? I understand that ARM is "western IP" but then why bring up the cost?
And what ecosystem do MIPS and ARM have that Power doesn't? OK, unreleased versions of the next desktop / server Windows will run on ARM, but where's the MIPS part? I view Power, MIPS, and ARM all about the same in regards to software ecosystems.
But seriously, uniformity in tech is sometimes good (standards) but standards can also constrain innovation. Standards are good in a mature industry. Is CPU design a mature industry? Kind of I guess.
The software reality though is increasingly, who cares? I don't know what runs underneath the last two phones I had (well, I do, but as a developer I didn't need to know).