Imagine if google had just developed a proper iMessage competitor in 2012, and made it a cornerstone product like gmail. We probably would actually have a competitive smartphone landscape in the US today.
The success of the iPhone was built on the culture of iPhone-first app development and the unwillingness of companies to develop for a third platform.
All google had to do was make an iMessage clone, probably even could have made a better service back then, and make it the default on all android phones. Suddenly Google would have had a powerhouse feature for the main thing phones were used for in 2012: communication.
But instead Google decided to leave SMS default and instead toy around with their stupid a/b model that nobody ended up using anyway.